The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[bear]

I was auctioning my UR Bee, these are my favorite Bids, which one is the fairest demand and rarity wise? c:
Thanks for any help! c:

Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 6
Bid 8 + add
Bid 10

first up, the UR bee is worth 2 non dogs, so

bid 3: unfair to you, their side may be a worth a little over 1 non but i wouldn't suggest going with it.
bid 4: The zonkey is roughly going for 1 - 2 nons so it depends what you value it at.
bid 6: The peach is currently valued at 1 - 2 sorbets, and i'm pretty sure the other pets added won't make up the difference between the UR bee and 2 sorbets worth^^. They'd need to add 4 sorbets or 1 sorbet and a non dog.
bid 8: Depends what you value the raven at, since it seems to be going from a sorbet level to non level right now. Either way you value it at, it would still be a bit unfair to you.
bid 10: UR cookie = 1 non & 1 sorbet, + the other sorbet, and the UR bee = 2 non dogs so they'd have to add 1 more sorbet to make it fair.

Personally bid 10 looks the best but it depends if you value the zonkey at 2 nons or not! good luck!

[Sali]

I was auctioning my UR Bee, these are my favorite Bids, which one is the fairest demand and rarity wise? c:
Thanks for any help! c:

Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 6
Bid 8 + add
Bid 10

first up, the UR bee is worth 2 non dogs, so

bid 3: unfair to you, their side may be a worth a little over 1 non but i wouldn't suggest going with it.
bid 4: The zonkey is roughly going for 1 - 2 nons so it depends what you value it at.
bid 6: The peach is currently valued at 1 - 2 sorbets, and i'm pretty sure the other pets added won't make up the difference between the UR bee and 2 sorbets worth^^. They'd need to add 4 sorbets or 1 sorbet and a non dog.
bid 8: Depends what you value the raven at, since it seems to be going from a sorbet level to non level right now. Either way you value it at, it would still be a bit unfair to you.
bid 10: UR cookie = 1 non & 1 sorbet, + the other sorbet, and the UR bee = 2 non dogs so they'd have to add 1 more sorbet to make it fair.

Personally bid 10 looks the best but it depends if you value the zonkey at 2 nons or not! good luck!

Thank you very much! C:

[bear]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66975428&userid=858758&signature=z6PEa_Z3KdK6pwVdxjHjkA Please help!

The bunny on their side is worth 6-7 Mixed 09 Rares + an 09 Uncommon.
Your side is the worth of 4 09 rares + the 09 uncommon (2016 store pets are worth a mid '10 rare).
You'd have to add 2-3 09 rares on your side to make it fair. I'm not really sure, but I don't think the unknown rarity dogs from this month make much a difference unless there's some demand on them that I haven't heard about^^.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66975501&userid=775738&signature=qZ2KGT9JbVqLKowZntF4IA

I am unsure how much the Malk Mutant goes for. Is this fair?

The malk mutant usually goes for a new 09 rares for overpay.
dark wood dog = 3-4 mixed 09 rares, and 2011 store pets are worth an early 09 rare.
if you're not going demand wise, this would be a perfectly fair trade up to a first tier advent list pet, or if you want to factor demand into the trade then you may want to consider it unfair to you^^.

[Airiss]

Is this a fair trades? Please, help!

1
2
3

[Quackers <3]

Can I get a few demand opinions on this? Thanks

[Airiss]

Is this a fair trades? Please, help!

1
2
3

[MotherMother]

Is this fair? Or this one? Thank you so much!

[Spearow]

Can I get a few demand opinions on this? Thanks :)

For me personally, if you do not have the alien dogs I would accept it. They're never getting re-released and a whole set for trade is not going to come around often. The aussie has good demand, and the shepherd so-so. But the birthday dog not so much. The store pet on your side isn't crazy high in demand either that I have noticed.

Up to you ^^

[Aphrodisiac]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66975501&userid=775738&signature=qZ2KGT9JbVqLKowZntF4IA

I am unsure how much the Malk Mutant goes for. Is this fair?

[musicgurl333]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66975501&userid=775738&signature=qZ2KGT9JbVqLKowZntF4IA

I am unsure how much the Malk Mutant goes for. Is this fair?

Unfair to you, regardless of the mutant's demand. Their pet is only worth about 3 '09 rares. The '11 store pets are worth about two '09 rares each, I believe and the mutant is an '09 rare but can go for a bit more with demand.