The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Stormwarden]

hi ! i was wondering if this is fair, and if not, how to make it so? i now know that a '16 store is worth a mid '10 rare, not an '09, but how much/what should i add to make it even?

[draco.]

Hello guys, I got an offer just now for my September list White Malk Dragon, and they are offering a Main List UR Rat. Here is the trade. Should I accept it?

[OHHAILTHECHOOKOFLIFE]

SECOND OPINIONS?????

I REALLY NEED SOME HELP WITH THIS!!!


What Trade Should I Take?????

Sunjewel bunny

Red grinner


Trade 1

Trade 2

Trade 3

trade 4

Trade 5

ANY help is appreciated

sunjewel bunny:
a sunjewel bun is worth 5 mid-advents, so this is quite unfair to them.

red grinner:
a grinner is worth 2 mid advents plus an '09 rare, so this is also unfair to them, but only by about an '09 rare.

trade one:
a palomino tess horse is worth 5 mid advents plus a candycane horse, but their demand isn't exactly the best, and it's hard in my opinion to trade them off fairly. however, with rarity, this trade is unfair to the palomino tess horse by about 1.5 mid-advents.

trade two:
as stated above, the palomino tess horse is worth 5 mid advents. this trade adds up to roughly 3, so it's unfair to them by about 2 mid-advents.

trade three:
2 fourth tier advents (the brown red-string horse) are worth 10-12 '09 rares together. your said adds up to 10-14 '09 rares, so this trade would be fair, but as stated above, tess horse demand isn't so great.

trade four:
the winged blood dog is worth roughly four mid advents. id say your side adds up to a little over four mid advents, so it's unfair to you by a little more than one '09 rare.

trade five:
as said above, the winged blood dog is worth four mid advents, so your side adds up to about 2.5. therefore, this is unfair to them by about 1.5 mid advents, and is a very good trade-up for you.

in summary, the sunjewel bun and the trade five winged blood dog are the best offers, but im not so sure on the demand of the bun. hope this helps.

Thank you
Any opinions with this with demand???
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8FFHndarKw

[pidge gunderson]

Is this fair for the both of us? Thanks!

the nonballoon is worth 34.5 mid-advents.
both the red x pps and the wolf pps are worth 10 mid-advents.
the target dog is worth 2 mid advents and a '09 rare.
therefor, i believe this is actually unfair to you.
10(2) + 2 = 22
22 ≠ 34.5
((if there's any calculation errors or factual errors let me know))

Thank you
Any opinions with this with demand???
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8FFHndarKw

demand for the rat kind of sucks, but with the right user you can still get a bit more than a sorbet, so this is very unfair to the other user. however, the timberwolves have great demand, so get a second opinion before acting on this trade.

[TheUnknown12]

Is this fair? Thank you for the help

[OHHAILTHECHOOKOFLIFE]

Thank you
Any opinions with this with demand???
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8FFHndarKw

demand for the rat kind of sucks, but with the right user you can still get a bit more than a sorbet, so this is very unfair to the other user. however, the timberwolves have great demand, so get a second opinion before acting on this trade.

Okay, Thank you! You have helped so much! Second opinions????

[draco.]

Hello guys, I got an offer just now for my September list White Malk Dragon, and they are offering a Main List UR Rat. Here is the trade. Should I accept it?

[mpdg]

help with this? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66740618&userid=885828&signature=o9DEkK5aSTCR-j2h9q_gHg

i'm not good with demand and dates-

[pidge gunderson]

could i get a few opinions on these trades?
1) the ur peach gets me every time
2) quantity of staff and items is great
3) im dying for the wigs and green toxic
4) the list and item quantity is jarringly great
5) this demand is amazing
thank you so much to everyone who helps.

also for ren hana:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WB2yLIP4IQ


is this fair? what should be added or changed? thank you

[bear]

Is this fair? Thank you for the help :)

I'd say unfair to them - their advent dog is worth 7-8 09 rares and your side is the value of 6 09 rares and 1 2010 rare^^
(the wolf figurine is worth 1 09 rare)