The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[dragonstars]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66731431&userid=865902&signature=IjWlEnMTvl6yMKqKdGy-zQ fair or over?

[lady gaga]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... B49F8JsmCg vs ur aussie??
thank you very much.

Happy~Face:
I would definitely take the first one. The yellow toxic has good demand and sometimes can go for overpay. The patchwork dog has super high demand and can go for main lists. And the sorbet is pretty good too.
But the UR ausssie doesn't have great demand... they can't really go for fair trades... kinda hard to trade off...
so personally I would much rather take the quantity one XDDDD Since the UR aussie is kinda hard to trade off fairly DX
Hope this helps! ♥︎

Bookshelf:
I've always found the UR aussie fairly easy to trade off for its regular value or at least a non, so I disagree.

Happy~Face
yea.... But I keep on getting offered UR aussie for my UR lion before (I have a UR lion before) and I've seen many people offering their UR aussie for the UR lion but got declined. And since the UR lion is a tier below the aussie, I thought they cannot go for fair trades lol!!! Like I dunno, maybe it's worth somewhere below the UR lion tier? XD (demand wise demand wise lololol)

Hope this helps! ♥︎

thank you, guys. could i have one more opinion on this? maybe some rarity talk?

Heres how I see these trades demand wise. Patchwork- I've seen offers for up to a green toxic, but people say it's more around the balloon/non balloon tiers. Yellow toxic- it's the same rarity as the green toxic, not quite sure if it fetches overpay but it is a nice pet. And the sorbet is good trade fodder if you'd like another pet I.e. Raven dog, patchwork, marionette etc. the Aussie, as I've said before, can go for nons or maybe slightly above, you'll just have to be patient.

Rarity wise. The patchwork is a tier 7 advent, toxic is below the gap mainlist, and the sorbet is a sorbet. The ur aussie is put at a non + sorbet, but I've almost always seen them go for underpay. The pets in the first trade all have decent demand and could be easier to trade off. It's also a nice "quantity" trade as there is more than one pet on their side. However, it all depends how you value the bun. If you value it at a non, an Aussie can go for a non but you may not be able to get the bun back if you wanted to or get a fair trade for the Aussie. The sorbet + toxic + patchwork may only add up to 2 sorbets if you value the patchwork at around the green toxic tier. So it all boils down to which you prefer/which one seems easier to you to trade off.

[Deku •ᴥ•]

would light leopard be fair for brown cake dog (what side should add and add what?)

[kkspecial4]

I know that this trade --> HERE <-- is unfair to me (thank you to those who helped)!

The above is the previous trade I received, this is what I sent back.

Is this newer trade more fair? --> HERE <--

[lady gaga]

would light leopard be fair for brown cake dog (what side should add and add what?)

The light leopard should add more as it's a few tiers lower than the cake dog (assuming it's that all brown one)

[Elwynie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66731342&userid=778181&signature=4KcgkPyy-NThAIDl3xibeA

Is this fair for the scourge?
I've been getting some offers (Really bad ones, like commons from 2017 for him)
and soooo
idk if this is fair or not to me ;-;
I've seen him go for a very rare once... sooo ye

I think it's fair(:
Scourge is worth a 2010 uncommon to a 09 rare even with his demand~

[עורב לבן]

Pretty sure they need more on their side, but what would balance it out? I know the sitting cats are in huge demand.

[MidnightDuchess]

nvm I got help somewhere else

[Saeyoung Choi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lpAAUgmNaA
Is this fair?

[Autvmn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66729609&userid=655344&signature=OG6ky5W1S08MdbDkarjT8Q

Is this fair? (: thanks!

Any help is greatly appreciated <3