The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Autvmn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66729609&userid=655344&signature=OG6ky5W1S08MdbDkarjT8Q

Is this fair? (: thanks!

[autumn magpie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 41JS20xrcQ


Is this fair? I feel like I might be overpaying a little with my older pets, but as long as it's not *massively* overdone I think I'll be alright with that, they have a lot of the butterfly wolves I need.

Thank you again

[bookshelf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66730150&userid=44278&signature=cNTgaZ1gLA_Y41JS20xrcQ


Is this fair? I feel like I might be overpaying a little with my older pets, but as long as it's not *massively* overdone I think I'll be alright with that, they have a lot of the butterfly wolves I need.

Thank you again

Very unfair to you, if I'm not mistaken just one of your '09 rares would be overpay.

[dragonstars]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MKqKdGy-zQ fair or over?

[kimii]

Is this a fair trade?
I'm fairly certain it's very unfair to me, but I wanted to make sure since I don't trade lists often.

[jiji]

Is this a fair trade?
I'm fairly certain it's very unfair to me, but I wanted to make sure since I don't trade lists often.

Yup. This is very unfair to you. Your cat goes for 2 Nons and 2 Sorbets usually.

[pilvt]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66731550&userid=892615&signature=Z--fGb3j-asnctf7-kr-Qw
Thank you in advance!

[Eagle's Eye]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66731550&userid=892615&signature=Z--fGb3j-asnctf7-kr-Qw
Thank you in advance!

Unfair to you as your pet is on the advent list. The top is worth roughly 2.25 '09 rares, which does not add up to any list pet

[TheUnknown]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AIDl3xibeA

Is this fair for the scourge?
I've been getting some offers (Really bad ones, like commons from 2017 for him)
and soooo
idk if this is fair or not to me ;-;
I've seen him go for a very rare once... sooo ye

[pidge gunderson]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... B49F8JsmCg vs ur aussie??
thank you very much.

Happy~Face:
I would definitely take the first one. The yellow toxic has good demand and sometimes can go for overpay. The patchwork dog has super high demand and can go for main lists. And the sorbet is pretty good too.
But the UR ausssie doesn't have great demand... they can't really go for fair trades... kinda hard to trade off...
so personally I would much rather take the quantity one XDDDD Since the UR aussie is kinda hard to trade off fairly DX
Hope this helps! ♥︎

Bookshelf:
I've always found the UR aussie fairly easy to trade off for its regular value or at least a non, so I disagree.

Happy~Face
yea.... But I keep on getting offered UR aussie for my UR lion before (I have a UR lion before) and I've seen many people offering their UR aussie for the UR lion but got declined. And since the UR lion is a tier below the aussie, I thought they cannot go for fair trades lol!!! Like I dunno, maybe it's worth somewhere below the UR lion tier? XD (demand wise demand wise lololol)

Hope this helps! ♥︎

thank you, guys. could i have one more opinion on this? maybe some rarity talk?