The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ThunderCedar]

I'm dying. The shima is my ultimate dream pet, I need opinions. I could accept this. AHHHH.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xVVIVgdleA

It's very unfair to you. Your blue rose dog is worth several times the shima, even with demand. The shim will go for a mid advent. Low September if you're lucky. A blue rose is way over the top. It's worth 7 mid advents and has some demand to it in itself. I would decline.

What about this one?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eY6PCHIYSg

Yup this one is roughly fair if you value the shima at a mid advent
If you really want it, I say go for it. Though you are likely going to struggle trading off the pink September, I'd say it's okay anyway.

[LiquidCake]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AOmN1QrH_g

is this fair? help ;;v;;

[ThunderCedar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66324501&userid=779325&signature=QLq2u5LcPqlfAOmN1QrH_g

is this fair? help ;;v;;

Unfair to you. Considering how recent their stores are, only 3 of your store pets are fair for their side. The rest of the quantity on their side only serves to cover the age gap , it wouldn't add up to a 4th store pet.
Tldr; just 3 of your store pets are enough

[the trickster]

Would the UR cinnabun and the UR cat together be fair for the moonswirl, if not, what would have to be added to make it fair? Also, is this fair?

Valuing the cinnamon bun at a non, and the ur cat at its true value, then it's unfair to the moonswirl. The ur cat's side would have to add a sorbet.
As for the 2nd trade it's unfair to you. Your dog is worth 6-7 09 rares and they're giving you the worth of approx 5 one of which has pretty bad demand.

Can I get another opinion?

[darwins]

is this fair?

[Vilhelm]

Would the UR cinnabun and the UR cat together be fair for the moonswirl, if not, what would have to be added to make it fair? Also, is this fair?

Valuing the cinnamon bun at a non, and the ur cat at its true value, then it's unfair to the moonswirl. The ur cat's side would have to add a sorbet.
As for the 2nd trade it's unfair to you. Your dog is worth 6-7 09 rares and they're giving you the worth of approx 5 one of which has pretty bad demand.

Can I get another opinion?

I agree with the opinion the second trade. And anyway, I heard that the blood dogs gi for more demand wise?

[LemonadeQueen]

I agree with the opinion the second trade. And anyway, I heard that the blood dogs go for more demand wise?

I don't agree with that. I think blood dogs go for their worth, not overpay.

[leilanii]

help is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... oIwefw-OUw

[Eagle's Eye]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66298275&userid=859283&signature=MAaQ9-fa9173oIwefw-OUw
is this fair?

Very unfair to them. A non list '11 store pet is worth two '09 rares. Your side is only worth one '09 rare since your green dog was extended into '09

[EmberzTale]

UR Grapes for UR Mint Horse?