The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[lysistraticmuse]

Does this seem fair ^^?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZYphTWJ70Q

[ChemicalWinter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66321378&userid=881613&signature=hSeL5jIu6px-_9v28uEaEw
Does this measure up demand-wise?

[LemonadeQueen]

Is this fair demand wise? If not what needs to be added/removed? Thanks!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AlpHcTIDKg

[the trickster]

Would the UR cinnabun and the UR cat together be fair for the moonswirl, if not, what would have to be added to make it fair? Also, is this fair?

[ThunderCedar]

Is this fair demand wise? If not what needs to be added/removed? Thanks!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AlpHcTIDKg

Unfair to them. An 09 rare is worth 4 2009 uncommons not 4 2010 ones

Would the UR cinnabun and the UR cat together be fair for the moonswirl, if not, what would have to be added to make it fair? Also, is this fair?

Valuing the cinnamon bun at a non, and the ur cat at its true value, then it's unfair to the moonswirl. The ur cat's side would have to add a sorbet.
As for the 2nd trade it's unfair to you. Your dog is worth 6-7 09 rares and they're giving you the worth of approx 5 one of which has pretty bad demand.

[Youmeanies]

Is this fair demand wise? If not what needs to be added/removed? Thanks!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AlpHcTIDKg

Unfair to them. An 09 rare is worth 4 2009 uncommons not 4 2010 ones

Yes, but one is also a warrior so I'd say it pretty much evens out. Depends on how you value each warrior, though!

[ThunderCedar]

Is this fair demand wise? If not what needs to be added/removed? Thanks!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AlpHcTIDKg

Unfair to them. An 09 rare is worth 4 2009 uncommons not 4 2010 ones

Yes, but one is also a warrior so I'd say it pretty much evens out. Depends on how you value each warrior, though!

That's not true. Both sides have a warrior. There's no point in over valuing either of them.
It's still unfair to the rare one.

[Faded;]

Spotted tribal+ gwj+ tier 6 bun+ tier3 bun= ur butterfly wolf?

[ThunderCedar]

Spotted tribal+ gwj+ tier 6 bun+ tier3 bun= ur butterfly wolf?

That's unfair to the bwolf. Both sides don't have great demand, the spotted tribal's side adds up to less than 2 nons whilst the bwolf is worth over 3 . This is gonna depend how you value each side though, since both don't have very good demand to them.
I'd personally keep the bwolf but some may prefer the quantity. I'd say it's up to you what you choose to make of the trade

[Odasakn]

XXX
;V; how much needs to be added to make this fair?? Thanks in advance!