The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Furfur]

Would this be fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66259639&userid=55976&signature=J60jmmGmA1DBJzmEJzfZQw

[ThunderCedar]

hi, i just wanted an opinion on this

thanks so much for any input!

in terms of dates and rarity, it seems pretty fair. the vc is pretty old, going by rarity math it's worth about half your cat in terms of general value. the other pets make up for the other half. it's an okay trade.

sounds good, thanks so much!!



i'm not typically a trader so i would really appreciate input on this as well ^^ ;; ; ;

13' rare is worth a 2011 uncommon. 16' rare is worth a 14' uncommon. 17' rare is worth 2 16' uncommons. the first 4 pets on their side are enough for yours. the rest is overpay on their part.

[Argentum]

13' rare is worth a 2011 uncommon. 16' rare is worth a 14' uncommon. 17' rare is worth 2 16' uncommons. the first 4 pets on their side are enough for yours. the rest is overpay on their part.

thank you, vixey, it's very appreciated. there seems to be an observable trend with the stacking of years and rarities so i'll keep that in mind for next time :~)

[ThunderCedar]

Would this be fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66259639&userid=55976&signature=J60jmmGmA1DBJzmEJzfZQw

the elven set was going for a 10' rare at release, so I think it's safe to say its value has about doubled since then and it should be worth about a 2009 rare now. Their C$ is worth about an 09 rare, so that's fair for the elven set. The rest of their pets are definitely overpay for your mirror necklace. I'd say this is unfair to them by rarity.
Though, just for your information, the elven set's demand is pretty good. Finding someone who'll trade it fairly is quite hard. It can easily go for more than its worth. some examples:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OVLLPPo0UQ (take this one with a grain of salt, because I don't have any context.)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... P9edPKXPuQ (note the bwolf is an 09 rare being offered on 2 pieces)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... O_kOxbeLQA (this one was a bid for the set, I believe somewhere in 2014)

[TsukiMegami]

Ok, desperately need a reply because I don't want to keep them waiting.

Is THIS trade fair?

I don't know since they are 2017 pets for 2014 but of course, I am new and don't know demand etc. etc.

PLEASE REPLY! :>

[Shadow2204]

Ok, desperately need a reply because I don't want to keep them waiting.

Is THIS trade fair?

I don't know since they are 2017 pets for 2014 but of course, I am new and don't know demand etc. etc.

PLEASE REPLY! :>

Demand is up to you, but their side is worth only a quarter of what your rare is worth, so personally, I'd decline.

[TsukiMegami]

Oh ok, thanks!

I sent THIS trade back, is this fair now?

Are they overpaying?

[zant.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8okrbi8-1A

How's this?
I'm not good with item trades but I've had people tell me this item is kinda valueable-ish while others tell me its not worth much of anything. And I can't find it in the archives (if anyone can tell me where it is in the archives that would be great) I want to make a fair trade, so what should be done? Or is this already fair?

[Shadow2204]

Oh ok, thanks!

I sent THIS trade back, is this fair now?

Are they overpaying?

No, it would be very unfair to them since the store pet tiger on their side is worth a 2010 rare.

[Furfur]

Would this be fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66259639&userid=55976&signature=J60jmmGmA1DBJzmEJzfZQw

the elven set was going for a 10' rare at release, so I think it's safe to say its value has about doubled since then and it should be worth about a 2009 rare now. Their C$ is worth about an 09 rare, so that's fair for the elven set. The rest of their pets are definitely overpay for your mirror necklace. I'd say this is unfair to them by rarity.
Though, just for your information, the elven set's demand is pretty good. Finding someone who'll trade it fairly is quite hard. It can easily go for more than its worth. some examples:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OVLLPPo0UQ (take this one with a grain of salt, because I don't have any context.)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... P9edPKXPuQ (note the bwolf is an 09 rare being offered on 2 pieces)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... O_kOxbeLQA (this one was a bid for the set, I believe somewhere in 2014)

Thank you for all the info!

I had no idea it was worth so much, really glad I asked. I don't do item trades much so its always hard for me to determine if a trade involving them it worth it or not.