The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Eagle's Eye]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=65844897&userid=738429&signature=QqwmftxVYJeL-trqmo0seA
holy hecc need some help tysm <3

Unfair to you. Their sitting cat can go for fair trades. Your side is worth a mid 2009 rare+a mid/late '09 rare (the tiger is worth a late '10 rare)

[tigres2003]

Is this a fair trade? Hows the bunnies demand?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GmzpSGj-EQ

[Kyar]

Cinnabon trades:

BEG + Toxic Rat
Non Sunjewel
UR Aussie + Lion Store pet set
Non Coon
Non Coon + Grinner and more (leading)

Which one should I take? I kinda like the idea of an above gap list but idk about the UR Aussies demand or which non has better demand. <3 tysm

Edit: Was this fair? Ik both the item and pet have good demand so idk <3

The most valuable cinnabon offer is the UR aussie - the grinner adds a little bit to the noncoon in that offer but in the grand scheme of things the grinner doesn't make a massive difference in terms of value - the gap between the non and aussie is about a sorbet if that helps.
I've heard a lot of people SAY the UR aussie has bad demand but I've never had that experience honestly - I wouldn't say that either is in particularly high demand but both should be fairly easy trades all in all. It depends a little bit on what you're after as well - it's always harder - for example - to get a large amount of quantity for a single pet no matter what you're offering. But all in all I'd personally say the aussie looks best to me as it has the most value by a pretty decent amount and comparable demand. :)
As for the scarf trade - that looks fine to me. :) Those store scarves are in very high demand but the vixen is also one of the most sought after mid advents and is always an easy trade - sometimes going for double its list placement or on very rare occasions even more than that. So I think as long as you were happy with it it was a fine trade. :)

is this fair rarity and demand wise?

People have been really… can I say nutty about store pets lately? Lol. They've been going for FAR more than it really makes any sense to just because at some point people started demanding main list pets which… exploded lol.
The advantage your side has is quantity but momentarily disregarding my personally affection for marionette dogs - the joker has always been a safe solid investment and a high-demand pet that will always be a good option to have. It's made a great trade booster or the perfect thing to coax someone out of another high demand pet - for example I used mine as part of a sunback trade - and in terms of value if you're putting the joker around its typical non you'd have to value the store pets AWFULLY high to meet that mark. Personally - I think in the grand scheme of things unless you get a CRAZY offer for the store pets the joker is probably a better deal.

Is this trade fair? I keep getting offers for my rare sitting cat constantly, should I just auction it or something?

Thanks in advance!

They're overpaying - those cats while popular are actually fairly common for their age and rarity - they were released and available to adopt for quite a long time. They're offering you two 2009 rares for them so yeah they're overpaying. As far as an auction goes it's possible you could get more but it's always a little hard to say - sometimes just advertising you have the pet is good enough if you don't want to go through the hassle of setting up an auction. :)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts/viewgroup.php?userid=713426&groupid=5657434
is this worth a sorbet? how much should i add?

Your group there is worth about a scarf PPS or so. You'd need to add in the area of a gearback tribal + a couple of advents/another low september for a sorbet dog.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=65844897&userid=738429&signature=QqwmftxVYJeL-trqmo0seA
holy hecc need some help tysm <3

That was unfair to you - that particular sitting cat is an advent as opposed to a warrior cat (which are the ones that tend to have some demand) so there's really no need for the store pet or 2010 cat - the pony alone would be a TINY bit of overpay for the cat (by about a month) but in terms of species differences I think that would be fine. :) So I would recommend the pony for the cat 1:1.

Would this be fair? Please and thank you :)

In terms of straight rarity they're overpaying just a touch. As far as demand goes the blood dog doesn't have particularly high demand by any means but it is a list pet so it's whether you'd prefer to have a list pet or a bit more in 2009 rares. :) It's a reasonable offer anyway.

[^-^ KAWAII]

Is this a fair trade? Please let me know as soon as possible!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... serid=8880

[Eagle's Eye]

Is this a fair trade? Please let me know as soon as possible!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... serid=8880

Wrong link, click share trade on the top right corner

[^-^ KAWAII]

Is this a fair trade? Please let me know as soon as possible!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... serid=8880

Wrong link, click share trade on the top right corner

Sorry, here you go! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8045&signa

[Eagle's Eye]

Is this a fair trade? Please let me know as soon as possible!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... serid=8880

Wrong link, click share trade on the top right corner

Sorry, here you go! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8045&signa

We still can't see it, part of the link is cut off

[tigres2003]

Is this a fair trade? Hows the bunnies demand?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GmzpSGj-EQ

[^-^ KAWAII]

Okay, this should be the correct link.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... w3hUFwxuYw

Is this a fair trade?

[cryptid.]

Is this a fair trade? Hows the bunnies demand?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GmzpSGj-EQ

they are overpaying by a lot! The bunny is a tier 6 while yours is only a tier 1. The sitting cat does have a little demand but not that much. And the bunny usually goes for fair trades

Okay, this should be the correct link.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... w3hUFwxuYw

Is this a fair trade?

They are overpaying! Their rat is a 2009 rare, while you pet is just a 2014 uncommon