The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[bertholdt]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... deL-D4JubQ

even with demand is this fair

[ʙʀᴏᴋᴇᴅ™]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64585943&userid=856410&signature=7S5dTtY9Dn3AdeL-D4JubQ

even with demand is this fair

I dont think so. Shimas go for lots. Even though the aussies have a good demand, i dont think so.

[Saeyoung Choi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0IVk329IjQ
Is this fair?

[onxzs]

is this trade fair?

if not what should be added?

[Coffeeeeeeee]

Another opinion please?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _YoZ_MEk2w
First opinion said: Yes, Toxics can be traded up easily.
Question: Any chance the Toxics could be traded up higher than what I traded for them? Example: Traded a Spotted tribal for them, gets low main mainlist (not gap mainlist)

Second Question: How much is a Toxic worth in either :Sept Lists, Mid-Advents, or 09' Rares?
My goal here is to convert my Spotted Tribal entirely to 09' rares. Please, don't judge me.

So, if you know my goal, getting 09' rares out of it, is it still fair, or over?

If I get two Toxics- would each toxic go for about 500/600 09' rares ? It would be a bit more work to trade them down- and down... and down...
and then down again...

blegh- I heard the Spotted tribal is worth 1.2k 09' rares (approx??)

If I traded for the Toxics, would I be losing any of those rares?
If I am losing under 50 09' rares, I will do it.
If there is a gap of over 50 09' rares, I will not do it.


More opinions please! :d

[ʙʀᴏᴋᴇᴅ™]

is this trade fair?

if not what should be added?

Rarity wise definitely unfair to you. Demand wise idrk. So get an opinion on that!

[onxzs]

is this trade fair?

if not what should be added?

Rarity wise definitely unfair to you. Demand wise idrk. So get an opinion on that!

ok tysm anyone else know?

[Fwutter]

Another opinion please?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _YoZ_MEk2w
First opinion said: Yes, Toxics can be traded up easily.
Question: Any chance the Toxics could be traded up higher than what I traded for them? Example: Traded a Spotted tribal for them, gets low main mainlist (not gap mainlist)

Second Question: How much is a Toxic worth in either :Sept Lists, Mid-Advents, or 09' Rares?
My goal here is to convert my Spotted Tribal entirely to 09' rares. Please, don't judge me. ;)

So, if you know my goal, getting 09' rares out of it, is it still fair, or over?

If I get two Toxics- would each toxic go for about 500/600 09' rares ? It would be a bit more work to trade them down- and down... and down...
and then down again...

blegh- I heard the Spotted tribal is worth 1.2k 09' rares (approx??)

If I traded for the Toxics, would I be losing any of those rares?
If I am losing under 50 09' rares, I will do it.
If there is a gap of over 50 09' rares, I will not do it.

:)
More opinions please! :d

Your side is worth 2 sorbets and their side is worth 1 sorbet + so it's unfair to you rarity wise. Demand is based off of personal preference.

[LemonadeQueen]

is this trade fair?

if not what should be added?

Rarity wise definitely unfair to you. Demand wise idrk. So get an opinion on that!

ok tysm anyone else know?

I agree. The UR Phoenix is a above gap Main list. Their side isn't worth anything near that... this trade is unfair to you.

[Fwutter]

is this trade fair?

if not what should be added?

Rarity wise definitely unfair to you. Demand wise idrk. So get an opinion on that!

ok tysm anyone else know?

I agree. The UR Phoenix is a above gap Main list. Their side isn't worth anything near that... this trade is unfair to you.

They need to add approximately the full worth of the UR pheonix which is a Non + a sorbet.