The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Coffeeeeeeee]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Tpip6gjlkw
pss help its a tier 8

[plisetsky]

help with these trades, please? the first ones are cancelled,
but im just curious if they wouldve been fair.
trade1
trade2
trade3

thank you!

[Horror]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jWxTvDOmYA

They said this was not fair. I'd like at least two people to tell me that this is fair so I can send it to them. I know it was fair,
they asked for 50 2017 rares, an unknown rarity store pet, about 4 '12 rares, about 8 '15/16 rares...
and then i reduced it to this,
and they didnt accept.

I think they were trying to rip you off or scam you. That pet only has the value of a 2008 pet. It isn't a listie.

I agree with Riften, you should talk this over with them and if they keep saying it report them, they were most likely trying to scam you.

I'd say your side is now is worth about a '10 rare + little over a '11 rare, considering 2017 rares are hardly worth much in this
It was slightly unfair to them rarity wise as their dog is worth a mid-late 2009 rare
In the original trade, It would've been fair if you offered recent store pet + the 4 '12 rares

[Bushy36]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64446950&userid=876083&signature=SjL0ScjENbg755KVxb7mYg
Was this fair for Leafpool?

unfair to you. even considering demand. by rarity just your 10' store pet was overpay, on its own. but you added an 09 rare sitting cat + more.

Thanks, second opinion anyone?

[Guest]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64455303&userid=864956&signature=7A2lcpaVbk5KjWxTvDOmYA

They said this was not fair. I'd like at least two people to tell me that this is fair so I can send it to them. I know it was fair,
they asked for 50 2017 rares, an unknown rarity store pet, about 4 '12 rares, about 8 '15/16 rares...
and then i reduced it to this,
and they didnt accept.


Did you count how much the pets are worth or are you just giving uneducated advice? Please take a look at the trade and do the rarity math before accusing someone of scam, thank you

I actually support Riften on this one. I'm pretty sure their horse is a re-release.
Even when added pets together in total, I'm pretty sure it's fair. EVEN if it wasn't, they could add a rare or a few uncommons.

Please do not get rude with other players for advice. Thank you.

The horse isn't a rerelase, it's a 2012 halloween event rare
Sorry if I came off as rude, I just don't think that it's fair to accuse someone of trying to scam other person when the trade was actually fair? Their side was worth 2 09 rares and 2 09 rares equals 1 08 rare, no? Anyway, this is not the place to discuss that, we will have to agree to disagree

[Shippe]

Is this fair? I'm super bad with item value. Thanks!

[Tea-]

Hello, Ive been wondering how could I make this fair. she/he asked me to edit but Idk...
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VEZT_7zTAg

[Kiwi<3]

x
Would this be fair demand wise? I received this for my auction.
Please send your thoughts in a PM, I'll probably forget to check this!

Any thoughts?

[Thinking.Kiwi]

I believe this is unfair to me but I'd like a second opinion!

[poison.wolf04]

Hi is this fair: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Db9Ag_85jQ
Thank you :3