The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Silverstar]

Thank you ^

is this fair? Not to sure on what a husky or the PPS dragon go fir

I would say fair.
A PPS dragon cat goes for about a low-mid advent and the husky a low advent (goes for overpay) and they have a nice store pet.

Go for another opinion to confirm what they go for :)

Thank you! Can I get another opinion please :')

I've received many trades for my pps dragon cat and I've never been offered an advent list, only a couple '09 rares, so this is an offer I would take.

[parted]

Hey

What do you think about these two trades?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63735680&userid=632280&signature=-vEDA061yr3xpEVEUVdEOQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63735696&userid=632280&signature=YBH5gxAR903uxI-va8ih_w

Thank you

[thrjholly]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63735657&userid=851538&signature=iIN1VYtDRyxKW81x7cizGA
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... iGdBy1tVUQ
are any of these fair??
thank you for your time

Both are definitely unfair since the cake dog is worth a Floppy Pink September & Candy Cane Horse and both trades are offering the worth of less than the lowest advent tier.

thank you🎈

[Shadow2204]

Hey :)

What do you think about these two trades?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63735680&userid=632280&signature=-vEDA061yr3xpEVEUVdEOQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63735696&userid=632280&signature=YBH5gxAR903uxI-va8ih_w

Thank you :)

1. Grinner is worth 13-17 '09 rares so it's unfair.
2. A Zodiac is usually valued as a '09 rare so the sitting cat would be fair to the zodiac. A 2010 common is also worth a 2013 rare (1 2010 c = 2 2011 c = 1 2011 uc = 2013 rare) And the 3 recent rares only adds up to a little more than a 2015 rare.

[Rusticsmile67]

Thank you ^

is this fair? Not to sure on what a husky or the PPS dragon go fir

I would say fair.
A PPS dragon cat goes for about a low-mid advent and the husky a low advent (goes for overpay) and they have a nice store pet.

Go for another opinion to confirm what they go for

Thank you! Can I get another opinion please :')

[parted]

Hey

What do you think about these two trades?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63735680&userid=632280&signature=-vEDA061yr3xpEVEUVdEOQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63735696&userid=632280&signature=YBH5gxAR903uxI-va8ih_w

Thank you

1. Grinner is worth 13-17 '09 rares so it's unfair.
2. A Zodiac is usually valued as a '09 rare so the sitting cat would be fair to the zodiac. A 2010 common is also worth a 2013 rare (1 2010 c = 2 2011 c = 1 2011 uc = 2013 rare) And the 3 recent rares only adds up to a little more than a 2015 rare.

Thank you!

[horchata]

how fair is this demand-wise? thankyou!

I usually see the speckled rat only going for a few advents, so I wouldn't take it. It's quite hard to get a rose pps out of it.

how fair is this demand-wise? thankyou!

They are overpaying by rarity of course.
Personally, I wouldn't accept it because i'm not a fan of rats. If you're looking for this rat, then you should accept. If you're looking to trade up more, I think you'd be better off with the Rose pps

okay thankyou both sm

[leiawolfe]

Thank you ^

is this fair? Not to sure on what a husky or the PPS dragon go fir

I would say fair.
A PPS dragon cat goes for about a low-mid advent and the husky a low advent (goes for overpay) and they have a nice store pet.

Go for another opinion to confirm what they go for

I agree with Shadow; I would accept this trade c:
PPS Dragon Cat: Worth a low advent, sometimes a mid-advent depending on your trading partner
Pink Husky: About a mid-advent with demand
2013 Store pet: Worth a late 2009 rare

[Born Dragonborn]

Is this fair for me?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QgvvVVnXlg
If not. What should i add/remove?

Edit: this trade also
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... v8IavNmcmA

[watery>~<]

Is this fair for me?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QgvvVVnXlg
If not. What should i add/remove?

This is very unfair to them. Because 4 very commons are worth one common and they're offering two commons for a very common. You would have to add 7 more very commons