The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[timothee]

help!! I really want this pet but I'm not so sure! thanks!

Got that it's not fair, but what would they need to add?

[muttgirl310]

I was wondering what the two malks would be worth in this trade? I feel like the 3 rares on my side are a bit too much but wanted another opinion.

[striped]

is this fair?

fair or ??

[Horror]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gclHaXKgxg

fair?

Unfair to the other side. Their bat is from '12 and your pets only add up to a '13 rare

[Hauntednightmares]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63719246&userid=867096&signature=p0EDYWysJ1RIMkUl6ucZSg

Was this fair? Rarity and demand wise.

[regulus black]

I was wondering what the two malks would be worth in this trade? I feel like the 3 rares on my side are a bit too much but wanted another opinion.

a 2010 uncommon is worth a 2012 rare, so you are overpaying - your owl is originally from 09.

[snoop]

did the august pps demand explode or??? obviously this is way over, should I take it? thanks in advance

[Elettra]

Is this trade fair? Thanks in advance!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... K4Tlzz-NfA

very unfair to them

Yes it's unfair but give an educated response please. The noncoon is worth about 3 sorbets and your side doesn't even add up to half of a sorbet.

Please do not give false advice.
The pet they were asking for is the coontail, which is worth 2 nons (or 6 sorbets).
Yes, it was drastically unfair to them. ^^

[ぽうひ]

fair?

[snoop]

did the august pps demand explode or??? obviously this is way over, should I take it? thanks in advance