The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kromer]

Thoughts? Will wait but would really appreciate fast response even if you are semi guessing.
TradeLink

Would also like more than one opinion. Ty!

I'd say about fair.

[Shadow2204]

Thoughts? Will wait but would really appreciate fast response even if you are semi guessing.
TradeLink

Would also like more than one opinion. Ty!

The lion is worth 20C$. So they're overpaying by 8C$.

[MidnightDuchess]

Thoughts? Will wait but would really appreciate fast response even if you are semi guessing.
TradeLink

Would also like more than one opinion. Ty!

I'd say about fair.

What is the tiger store pet worth if its "about" fair? (would like your opinion just as much as anyone's)

[MidnightDuchess]

Thoughts? Will wait but would really appreciate fast response even if you are semi guessing.
TradeLink

Would also like more than one opinion. Ty!

The lion is worth 20C$. So they're overpaying by 8C$.

Much appreciated.

[Shadow2204]

Should I accept? Would you personally accept?

The blue ice rat alone is overpaying by about 8 advents so adding the other pets, that's about 4-5 more advents.
Would I personally accept? No, simply because I never accept trades with list rats. Should you accept? Depends.
Honestly, if you try trading off the ice rat, it'd be hard to get a batdog's worth (or more) from it. So you'd probably get less than the batdog's worth.
I feel like you could get a better offer on the batdog.

[xXFallenXx]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63627968&userid=317611&signature=UpRoG2EDQUgRiO5aUQPmIg

Need help please, Idk if what I offered is overpay or underpay, I think underpay

[Hauntednightmares]

Should I accept? Would you personally accept?

The blue ice rat alone is overpaying by about 8 advents so adding the other pets, that's about 4-5 more advents.
Would I personally accept? No, simply because I never accept trades with list rats. Should you accept? Depends.
Honestly, if you try trading off the ice rat, it'd be hard to get a batdog's worth (or more) from it. So you'd probably get less than the batdog's worth.
I feel like you could get a better offer on the batdog.

Ok! Any other opinions.

[Shadow2204]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63627968&userid=317611&signature=UpRoG2EDQUgRiO5aUQPmIg

Need help please, Idk if what I offered is overpay or underpay, I think underpay

The cat is worth an early '10 rare or a late '09 rare by rarity. With demand, it could go for a decent early/mid '09 rare. You're offering a late '09 rare so technically, it's fair (you're overpaying by the 2010 rare + the 2015 rare).

I'd say it's about fair, however, people may expect more from store pets.

[capone.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63628148&userid=181755&signature=1WTzmBsCuG_tlBkvEGPNfA
fair? i know nothing about items,,,
thanks so much !

edit;;
this one too !!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ILBwjqJjJQ

[whimerri]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63627872&userid=805700&signature=SMPZDOyfANQsQmbDJJlLHg
This fair?

Repost