The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kromer]

how does this trade look?

They're asking for slight overpay if I'm correct; A '13 store pet is only worth a mid '09 rare, but your dog is from early '09, but just re-released.

[Ghoulflower]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gwaXdPsLdA

is this fair for my dark leopard? thanks!

[leiawolfe]

how does this trade look?

They're asking for slight overpay if I'm correct; A '13 store pet is only worth a mid '09 rare, but your dog is from early '09, but just re-released.

Just adding onto this; the german shepherd has qiute high demand for an '09 rare, so yes, they'd need to add c:

[Tylerr Joseph]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63624729&userid=855626&signature=gK9ibte5kjuXX-iwJRYNCA

Is this fair? Its for my auction.

They are over paying because of dates.

[NineTail]

Is this fair by rarity, date, and demand?

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63622091&userid=761439&signature=2dxH3lk5I-tvgwaXdPsLdA

hello! is this fair for my dark leopard? thanks!

Their side is worth roughly 27 '09 + a 10 rare + 1 2016 rare + 1 2017 rare. This can get you about a mid september list pet and the dark leopard is on the highest tier on the sept. list. So this is unfair to you.

[sapphirelion]

trade

My trade involves the newest store pets and an older rare and I'm not sure what each is worth compared to the other so if anyone could help that would be nice and thank you to anyone who can help in advance

I saw the past response and thank you! I'm just getting more opinions to cement that

So may I have another opinion?

[leiawolfe]

trade

My trade involves the newest store pets and an older rare and I'm not sure what each is worth compared to the other so if anyone could help that would be nice and thank you to anyone who can help in advance

I saw the past response and thank you! I'm just getting more opinions to cement that

So may I have another opinion?

Unfair to you. Each '17 store pet is worth a mid '10 rare. That is just one '09 rare, which doesn't equal two '10 rares.

[Kitkat2716]

trade

My trade involves the newest store pets and an older rare and I'm not sure what each is worth compared to the other so if anyone could help that would be nice and thank you to anyone who can help in advance

I saw the past response and thank you! I'm just getting more opinions to cement that

So may I have another opinion?

Unfair to you. Each '17 store pet is worth a mid '10 rare. That is just one '09 rare, which doesn't equal two '10 rares.

Actually 2 2010 rares are equal to 1 2009 rare. I believe.

[plutone]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63624463&userid=645352&signature=TpTVGuqnDfxuhrU5Q7pr1A
is this fair? i really want the chicken dollars for the store pets this month but can't tell if it's over