The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[oodles]

what would have to be fixed to make this fair?

i really need some help with this.. could someone give me an opinion?

[Shadow2204]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63602813&userid=760847&signature=Np3uJIFIWgqwGHzXfL3eCw
Could I get any advice on this trade? Thank you in advance!~

Malk elements goes for a few '09 rares with demand, but it varies with who you trade with and how you personally value demand.
They're only offering you about a '09 rare + a 2012 rare of overpay.
Personally, i'd expect more (especially because their store pet & rare rats don't have the best demand).

But overpay, they're overpaying, so it's "fair".

[~Ｅｌｉａｓ Ａｉｎｓｗｏｒｔｈ~]

help???

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Q7Ttxp91kw

[watery>~<]

Is a 09 very rare Graystripe warrior cat, 2 '09 rares, 1 '10 rare, Re-release Red-X (September list), a very rare robot rat (2016) and This worth more or a full set of zodiac dogs, pocky, PPS Unicorn store pet, 5 '09 rares, 2 '09 commons, 2017 lion storepet, 5 2016 rares, 2 '10 uncommons, 1 2017 common and 4 2017 very commons?


Thanks to anyone who helps me!

Pls Help me I rlly need it since I gtg soon

[Shadow2204]

help???

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Q7Ttxp91kw

Your pets are worth about 20-25C$ i'd say. So the pets are worth 40-50C$ together. Though, the dino has more demand and the unicorn has less demand so 45C$ isn't too bad of an offer.
Yes, the trade is fair because it's within the worth range.

[Shadow2204]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63605202&userid=650270&signature=oPVfrvuz_TzzswyzAXRZEw

i feel like they're overpaying, but i'm not sure. could i have some help? tyvm!!

Yep, they're overpaying.
Your store pet is worth only 30-35C$ so the C$ alone would be overpay. Yes, older store pets do go for overpay and I think that the overpay they are offering is well enough.

[Hauntednightmares]

Should I accept? What must be added or taken away?

[Sanctus]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DCQTEeR8Zg

Please help! Is this fair?

[oodles]

what would have to be fixed to make this fair?

i really need some help with this.. could someone give me an opinion?

[Shadow2204]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63603279&userid=854367&signature=vcT6hfzc19SKDCQTEeR8Zg

Please help! Is this fair?

Unfair to the lion.The lion is a tier 4 advent, worth 5-6 Mixed 09 Rares.
You're only offering about a little more than 4 '09 rares.