The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[zeedie]

How would this be?
Link

[Kabuski]

-Items-
1
2
Questions on items:
Are either of the trades fair?
If not what do my items add up to?

[magically]

Ahh, the smell of a fresh new thread!
Was this (http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Opr_D9TQGg) fair? Thanks!

Quite unfair to you. A 2012 common is worth two 2016 rares
(Valuing an uncommon as two commons and a rare as four uncommons)

I agree, very unfair to you. Their side only adds up to a 2015 Common, while yours is from 2012.

Oh, okay! Thank you to both of ya!

[Tally-Mark]

XXX
Is this fair?

[Eagle's Eye]

XXX
Is this fair?

Unfair to you due to the three month rule. They should add roughly a 2013/2014 uncommon

[Ranger of the North]

Kia ora!
How's this looking so far? What would need to be added?
Thanks in advance! <3

[gloaming]

How would this be?
Link

i'd say very unfair to you! even with the c$ i don't think that the sept list & the advent get anywhere close to the toxic's worth (plus trading list for c$ is also a dicey situation in my experience)
get a second opinion though!

[_BlackWidow_]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63066526&userid=754849&signature=j_kMS9T8utXj6NTEKKWf6A

Opinions demand wise?

[felix.]

How would this be?
Link

i'd say very unfair to you! even with the c$ i don't think that the sept list & the advent get anywhere close to the toxic's worth (plus trading list for c$ is also a dicey situation in my experience)
get a second opinion though!

agreed, the gap between their sept list dog and your toxic is too wide to fill with a few rares and the c$

[watery>~<]

Is this trade fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... x__yJ60GSA