The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[eros]

Was this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=63190816
This is what they said, "Unfair to me, 'cuz 2013 store pets worth like 2009 rares"

wrong link! you'll have to click the '[share trade]' button!

[Mewfle]

How does this trade look?
Raven for Brown Sleipnir+Patchwork+Yellow Toxic
Thank you in advance

Huh... I don't know, they are trading two 2010 VR for one 2010 VR.

Was this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=63190816
This is what they said, "Unfair to me, 'cuz 2013 store pets worth like 2009 rares"

Please don't give out false advice! Also check the front page to how you can get the correct link c:


As for the raven trade;
Ravens are still going for a non surprisingly, however it depends on how you value it. The sleipnir seems to be valued at a sorbet. Patchworks tend to go for septembers, and let's just leave the yellow toxic at it's list placement.

It seems like that demand wise, it's unfair to them by roughly 1.5 sorbets. However, please keep in mind that while demand may cause pets' worth to sky rocket, it will always come down again. The raven is just an advent, and the yellow toxic is a main list.

[Aethryn]

I'm auctioning off Scourge (the Warrior Cat)
Could I hear your opinion on the bids, please?

Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 9
Bid 10

Thanks in advance!

[Faux]

I'd say Bid 5 is the leading one out of these if you value Leafpool at a 09' rare since there's already a 09' rare in the bid which makes it a total of about 2 09' rares (plus the other stuff in the bid) but you should get more opinions

I'm auctioning off Scourge (the Warrior Cat)
Could I hear your opinion on the bids, please?

Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 9
Bid 10

Thanks in advance!

[Mewfle]

I'd say Bid 5 is the leading one out of these if you value Leafpool at a 09' rare since there's already a 09' rare in the bid which makes it a total of about 2 09' rares (plus the other stuff in the bid) but you should get more opinions

I'm auctioning off Scourge (the Warrior Cat)
Could I hear your opinion on the bids, please?

Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 9
Bid 10

Thanks in advance!

Yes, bid 5 seems to be the best one, however personally I would wait for more bids ^^
Just to clarify; that '10 uncommon is just a normal '10 uncommon that goes for fair trades c:

[Eagle's Eye]

I'm auctioning off Scourge (the Warrior Cat)
Could I hear your opinion on the bids, please?

Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 9
Bid 10

Thanks in advance!

Bid 3: Their side is only worth roughly a 2012 uncommon. This is very unfair to you, don't consider this offer
Bid 4: They're offering a late 2009 rare which could be traded off easily
Bid 5: Their side is basically an average demand late 2009 rare+2010 uncommon which can be traded off easily. The recent pets don't matter here.
Bid 6: The female lion is from Halloween 2010. Value wise, this is less than bid 4 or 5.
Bid 7: Very unfair to you. Their side is worth roughly a 2012 uncommon, don't consider this one.
Bid 8: They're offering less than bids 4,5,6. This is also below average for what an uncommon warrior usually goes for.
Bid 9: The fox is from Valentines 2010. Value wise, this offer is less than bid 4 and 5 and more than bid 6
Bid 10: (Ignoring the "solar earing" item because I don't recognize it, sorry! Ask someone else for its value) the items from "dream sand" and onwards are all from 2013 or more recent years, so their values are small enough to be ignored here. The pets would be roughly worth a 2010 uncommon+2011 uncommon, which is below average for what an uncommon warrior goes for. Also, it's worth less than bid 4,5,6,9 without the solar earing!

Bid 4&5 are the best value wise with a slight gap between them. What species you prefer is up to you

[Aethryn]

I'm auctioning off Scourge (the Warrior Cat)
Could I hear your opinion on the bids, please?

Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 9
Bid 10

Thanks in advance!

Bid 10 is changed, what do you think?

[Bleating Ram]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YANfiOVKXw

Is this fair??

[Eagle's Eye]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63185289&userid=665435&signature=ENNe8UAN0kl1YANfiOVKXw

Is this fair??

Unfair to you. A late 2009 rare is worth 30-35C$

[Odasakn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZipD1cZ3iQ

Is this fair??