The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Eagle's Eye]

What about demand?

Ridiculously unfair to the top. Summer event pets are easy to trade off, but they're offering a 2009 rare. A 2013 rare is worth close to nothing compared to that

[NineTail]

Is this fair? Thanks!
Boop

[Pinesong]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MRZDumLPkA

That fair? ^^

[Happy~Face]

What about demand?

Ridiculously unfair to the top. Summer event pets are easy to trade off, but they're offering a 2009 rare. A 2013 rare is worth close to nothing compared to that

Demand-wise, I believe the Slumber party dog (the one on your side) has really high demand while the nick has bad demand and cannot go for fair trades. This is overpay of course but personally I wouldn't accept, I have one of those, and I've been offered a lot more c: So I suggest you to wait for better offers XD It's your choice though! XD

[CC-chips108]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FEbpW17VHA
?

[Eagle's Eye]

What about demand?

Ridiculously unfair to the top. Summer event pets are easy to trade off, but they're offering a 2009 rare. A 2013 rare is worth close to nothing compared to that

Demand-wise, I believe the Slumber party dog (the one on your side) has really high demand while the nick has bad demand and cannot go for fair trades. This is overpay of course but personally I wouldn't accept, I have one of those, and I've been offered a lot more c: So I suggest you to wait for better offers XD It's your choice though! XD

I disagree. Older Nick pets could easily go for fair trades, as there are Nick collectors out there. I've even seen quite a few 2009 Nicks go for overpay

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63190541&userid=855492&signature=lFBbQlyA3d98MRZDumLPkA

That fair? ^^

Their dog is worth 3-4 2009 rares. Value wise you're overpaying slightly over since one of your dogs is from 2008, but most people don't like to trade off list.

[Mewfle]

What about demand?

Ridiculously unfair to the top. Summer event pets are easy to trade off, but they're offering a 2009 rare. A 2013 rare is worth close to nothing compared to that

Demand-wise, I believe the Slumber party dog (the one on your side) has really high demand while the nick has bad demand and cannot go for fair trades. This is overpay of course but personally I wouldn't accept, I have one of those, and I've been offered a lot more c: So I suggest you to wait for better offers XD It's your choice though! XD

Nick pets' demand varies, some may say they go for overpay, others say that it has terrible demand and goes for underpay. Some just value it as a regular '09 pet. Obviously this trade is drastically unfair to the top as alpha has said. It's practically offering 10 times the worth of your pet c:
However whether you want to take it or not is up to you entirely.

[CC-chips108]

Ur ice cat + 1581 c$ = SUNJEWEL?

[lilystar]

How does this trade look?
Raven for Brown Sleipnir+Patchwork+Yellow Toxic
Thank you in advance

[Slumber]

How does this trade look?
Raven for Brown Sleipnir+Patchwork+Yellow Toxic
Thank you in advance

Huh... I don't know, they are trading two 2010 VR for one 2010 VR.

Was this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=63190816
This is what they said, "Unfair to me, 'cuz 2013 store pets worth like 2009 rares"

Wrong link..can't view the trade c: