The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Eagle's Eye]

Is this fair? I know it's very unfair to them rarity wise, but does their side have any list value or something, or is it just a regular '09 very rare? I'm very confused about this one.

boop

It's a normal very rare, so the fairness of this trade would depend on how you value warrior cats. If you value each of them as a mid 2010 rare, then this would be fair

[chocolatealba]

is this fair? if not what do i need to add
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ivlf3gg54w

[sunzie]

Is this a fair trade for a Blue Rose Dog?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QNcdJx9_Ig

[regulus black]

Is this a fair trade for a Blue Rose Dog?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QNcdJx9_Ig

strictly speaking, your side is worth 6 mid advents + a low advent, while the blue rose is worth 7. you should add 2-3 09 rares c:

[Scarlett.]

Can I get some opinions on this trade please?
I don't really want the rat, sitting cat and the '17 sheep c:

[luc]

Is this fair? I'm bad at item rarities.

[kiono]

Whats better by demand+worth?
►1
►2
►3

[Eagle's Eye]

Can I get some opinions on this trade please?
I don't really want the rat, sitting cat and the '17 sheep c:

The rat is a fair swap with your dog. Value wise, they're overpaying with the late 2009 rare sitting cat and the 2014 store pet (which is worth a late 2009 rare/early 2010 rare). The other pets don't really matter here

[SabrinaB]

Which trade is best for my Nick laptop?
Ignore the pet on my side, it's to auto cancel other bids.
The item will be added in.

Bid 4
Bid 8 + this
Bid 9

[beemo]

Is this fair? I'm bad at item rarities.

I'd say they're overpaying, personally. None of those items are particularly rare, and none of them are from 2009. I don't believe they're from 2010 either.