The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kiono]

How was this trade?
I just got the scarf today, so I'm not too sure what it typically goes for. ^^ Please answer only if you are knowledgable about items! Thank you c:

They are overpaying by a lot. Pretty unfair for them.

Thank you! another opinion please? c:

I think it's a huge overpayment on their part. 2010 Store scarfs are worth an early 09 rare or very rare.

[Yeens]

fair?

[Elettra]

How was this trade?
I just got the scarf today, so I'm not too sure what it typically goes for. ^^ Please answer only if you are knowledgable about items! Thank you c:

They are overpaying by a lot. Pretty unfair for them.

I think it's a huge overpayment on their part. 2010 Store scarfs are worth an early 09 rare or very rare.

I know rarity wise it was unfair to them, but what about demand? The entire store scarf set seems to go for quite a lot; do the individual scarves go for a lot too? Thank you! c:

[Ofenkartoffel]

How would this trade be?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Y8fRT8bimA

Thank you in advance

[sunzie]

Is this a fair trade for a Blue Rose Dog?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QNcdJx9_Ig

[kiono]

Whats better by demand+worth?
►1
►2
►3

[Hansendiet]

Hi ^^
Is this a fair trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vOPk2uzjlw

[Yeens]

fair?

[Eagle's Eye]

Hi ^^
Is this a fair trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vOPk2uzjlw

2010 uncommon=2012 rare
Their is 7 2017 rares, which is roughly 1.5 2015 rares // a bit less than a 2014 rare
Unfair to you

[turtle...]

How was this trade?
I just got the scarf today, so I'm not too sure what it typically goes for. ^^ Please answer only if you are knowledgable about items! Thank you c:

They are overpaying by a lot. Pretty unfair for them.

I think it's a huge overpayment on their part. 2010 Store scarfs are worth an early 09 rare or very rare.

I know rarity wise it was unfair to them, but what about demand? The entire store scarf set seems to go for quite a lot; do the individual scarves go for a lot too? Thank you! c:

I have not seen a single scarf go for more than a low september I believe c: in my opinion they are overpaying by a lot