The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Eagle's Eye]

Is this a good offer on my zodiac?

Zodiacs usually go for 1-2 2009 rares. That dog is from early 2009, so this is a pretty good offer. I personally wouldn't pay more than 1.5 2009 rares for a zodiac. Value wise, that dog is worth two zodiacs.

[Relara]

would you personally accept this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... TguCBqWdLg

[luc]

Is this a good offer on my zodiac?

Zodiacs usually go for 1-2 2009 rares. That dog is from early 2009, so this is a pretty good offer. I personally wouldn't pay more than 1.5 2009 rares for a zodiac. Value wise, that dog is worth two zodiacs.

Thank you! (:

[luckydraw]

is this fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... l2gWIz8Saw
thanks in advance

[Eagle's Eye]

is this fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... l2gWIz8Saw
thanks in advance

Their 2009 rare alone is fair. So they're overpaying with the 2010 dog

[Astrxl]

So I started a AUCTIOn for my 2014 corgi and a 2013 masked wolf. Here are the bids
1
2
3
4
5
i don't know which ones are fair and which aren't Idk they all seem fair to me, but idk demand wise.

[faunsie]

Trade
Demand wise is this fair (is the red x in more demand or the angel advent)

[dddddonuts]

Hi, I'm not the best with non-rare pets with older dates- I'd appreciate any help I could get with this ^^

[Eagle's Eye]

So I started a AUCTIOn for my 2014 corgi and a 2013 masked wolf. Here are the bids
1
2
3
4
5
i don't know which ones are fair and which aren't Idk they all seem fair to me, but idk demand wise.

Demand is up to you. I see these store pets either go for fair trades, or slight overpay.
The corgi is worth a late 2009 rare, and the 2013 masked store pet is worth a mid 2009 rare.
First trade is overpay. They're offering 2.5 2009 rares for your corgi
Second trade is also overpay, but not as much as the first bid. The top is worth 1.5 2009 rares
Third trade is ridiculous, it doesn't even come close to the worth of a '09 rare.
Fourth trade: They're offering 5.5 2009 rares for your two pets. They're overpaying
Fifth trade: That horse had an extended release until May 2009. Value wise they're overpaying a bit

I personally like bid 1 the most due to the overpay value wise. Bid 4 has pets that could be a bit harder to trade away

[Eagle's Eye]

Hi, I'm not the best with non-rare pets with older dates- I'd appreciate any help I could get with this ^^

Unfair to you. I value an uncommon as two commons, so their 2011 common cancels out half the worth of your 2011 uncommon. That makes it a 2011 common for a 2015 common, 2016 uncommon, and 3 2017 uncommons. Valuing a rare as four uncommons, a 2011 common is worth a 2014 rare. Their remaining side is worth less than a 2016 rare.