The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[DBD]

I canceled this trade, but they said "I think this should be enough..." Although I'm 99% it isn't. Was I correct?

Broken Link ^^

Ah! I'm half asleep. Here is the correct one!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DJALb_8vFg

This was my first mistake like this...

[✧ serendipity ✧]

I canceled this trade, but they said "I think this should be enough..." Although I'm 99% it isn't. Was I correct?

Broken Link ^^

Ah! I'm half asleep. Here is the correct one!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DJALb_8vFg

This was my first mistake like this...

The BA can go for a sorbet, but it really depends how you value the BA. Demand wise, unfair to you.

[DBD]

Ah! I'm half asleep. Here is the correct one!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DJALb_8vFg

This was my first mistake like this...

The BA can go for a sorbet, but it really depends how you value the BA. Demand wise, unfair to you. Rarity wise, it's slightly overpay on their side.

Huh, but they only have one list pet on their side, which is an advent list. And those items aren't exactly diffcult of find.

[juyeo]

Hi! Is this a fair trade if you incorporate demand? If not, what could be added to make it fair? Thank you in advance! :-)

They would need to add an '09 rare to make it fair c:. Demand wise, I've seen that specific deer go for a lot, but demand is based on you and your partner c:

Thank you! Can I have a few other opinions please? c:

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Ah! I'm half asleep. Here is the correct one!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DJALb_8vFg

This was my first mistake like this...

The BA can go for a sorbet, but it really depends how you value the BA. Demand wise, unfair to you. Rarity wise, it's slightly overpay on their side.

Huh, but they only have one list pet on their side, which is an advent list. And those items aren't exactly diffcult of find.

rarity wise even its unfair to you
The BA does have good demand too and can get better offers ^^

[luc]

I accepted this trade, but I noticed the dog i gace them actually came out in august 08, but does the extended release make up for the date difference? thank you in advance ^w^

[2FrostyPaws]

Is this trade fair? Thank you in advance!

[juyeo]

Hi! Is this a fair trade if you incorporate demand? If not, what could be added to make it fair? Thank you in advance!

They would need to add an '09 rare to make it fair c:. Demand wise, I've seen that specific deer go for a lot, but demand is based on you and your partner c:

Thank you! Can I have a few other opinions please? c:

[luc]

I accepted this trade, but I noticed the dog i gace them actually came out in august 08, but does the extended release make up for the date difference? thank you in advance ^w^

[Sinbreaker]

Is this trade fair? Thank you in advance!

Unfair to you. I think they need to add another 2010 rare + 2010 uncommon to close the gap, or get it close.
But I would seek a second opinion ^^

I accepted this trade, but I noticed the dog i gace them actually came out in august 08, but does the extended release make up for the date difference? thank you in advance ^w^

I would say it's okay. Yes the dog has an extended release but that sort of blurs the value of it between 2008 and 2009. Different people value them at different levels, but usually only an uncommon is needed to fill the gap. I think the trade is fine and fair.