The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Loki~Neith]

Fair? She said because of demand of her pet that I should at least add 1 sitting cat.http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wRRhRGB_CA

[Horror]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62932095&userid=737836&signature=nThQ26qCeNJaSRLj8-BYzw
Is this fair?

Its a fair swap if not overpay on their side demand wise. Yea its not a warrior but it's still a sitting cat so it does have high demand.

Demand varies from person to person. Warriors generally have high demand and the regular sitting cats don't unless that user particularly likes them. Not everyone wants sitting cats.
It's unfair rarity wise as well, the cat is a late 09 while yours is early.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62932146&userid=651644&signature=rWsHcJoSwi9KSFZZwwRAiQ fair?

Extremely unfair too you rarity wise. The marionette dog is only worth 4-5 '09 rares since its on the tier 3. If you count 1 vr = 2 rares. You've traded away 30 '09 rares for the marionette. This also includes the the sock dog in the trade making it even more fair since its 7 tiers higher then the marionette.

Demand wise. This is unfair. The marionette goes for a sorbet because of its demand. A sorbet is a mid/below gap main list. Even with all those pets it doesn't add up to even a low main list pet.

So rarity wise pits extremely unfair to you.
Demand wise its unfair to the marionette.

The marionette could get up to a sorbet, and most people wouldn't pay that much for it. That's closer to the ravens demand. The marionette can get a high september or anywhere to a main but a sorbet seems like a bit too much.
Saying it goes for a sorbet just drives it's price up.

[Ꭺlina]

How many sorbs. add up to each side in this trade?
If mines under the amount of sorbs. needed for the nons, How many nons will need to be taken away?
Also, is a UR peach worth a non+, or no?

The Spotted tribal is worth around 1,5 sorbets, the peach hasn't been going for nons lately. No one can say you what it's worth as it hasn't been placed yet but lately it often went for 1-1,5 sorbets, so the spottet tribal + peach are worth around a non together.

The other pets on your side are worth less than a sorbet together so you would have to remove three nons on their side and the Nonballoon and the non-list stuff on your side.
Or you have to remove two nons on their side and add 2 sorbets + around a rose pps on your side to make it fair for two nons.

[rentheidiot]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62911628&userid=856610&signature=LBDy3ErlPgA0q40ai0RuTwCan someone help me??

[lilystar]

Howa does this look?
I'm not really sure what the brown sleipnir goes for usually
Thank you in advance

[LostInTheEcho]

Could anyone help me with this trade? How can it be made fair? What needs to be added / removed? What's the difference in value between the two sides? Thank you for any help!

[Kabuski]

Is this bid + add on unfair to them?

are pocky boxes worth that much?

[Birchii]

Is this bid + add on unfair to them?

are pocky boxes worth that much?

Don't know about the bid, but the Pocky is worth a late 08 rare (listed here), so a Main list pet for it wouldn't be fair; you are overpaying. I believe the most it will go for is a mid advent, but you're best getting other opinions on that, and just to check my response too C:

[Niragi]

Is this bid + add on unfair to them?

are pocky boxes worth that much?

Don't know about the bid, but the Pocky is worth a late 08 rare (listed here), so a Main list pet for it wouldn't be fair; you are overpaying. I believe the most it will go for is a mid advent, but you're best getting other opinions on that, and just to check my response too C:

I agree, the most I've seen the pocky go for is a tier 6 bunny, at least lately. It used to go for more but nowadays it's going for a few 09 rares at most ^^

[SteampunkAngel]

Don't know about the bid, but the Pocky is worth a late 08 rare (listed here), so a Main list pet for it wouldn't be fair; you are overpaying. I believe the most it will go for is a mid advent, but you're best getting other opinions on that, and just to check my response too C:

Yeah, I've traded for quite a lot of pocky in the past and never would have paid as much as a main list myself. The item guide is outdated so the value guidance is probably under it's worth, but pocky have never been incredibly hard to get hold of.