The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[juyeo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62905129&userid=314897&signature=Zp6MAKTF55h1vHBxu1UYWw
Would this be fair? The two re-released dogs are from October 2009~

Well the warrior cat the uncommon one can go for 09 rares but the rare ones can go for 08 rares I believe not sure but I think they are overpaying

Thank you! Can I get a second opinion?

I can confirm this I have the uncommon warrior cat several times and got a 09 rare or more for it every time I traded it off. Plus, their 09 rare dogs are a few months older than yours, past the 3 month rule, so even that's overpay. Warrior cats in general have good demand so yeah, I'd go for it.

[nat13]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... W0L31YY00A
Hi! Would someone please tell me if this would be a fair trade?
Oh and also I have another one of those bird-bunnies so I'm more willing to give it away.
Thanks

[|Lace|]

My auction for my full set of the '17 store lions has been going on for a long time and I only got 2 bids, but 1 got cancelled.
Should I just auto this bid? Or should I just wait for a better one to auto?

[saucycorndog]

?? my sister got a trade and was wondering if it was fair or not, please help if you can ty!

[the fool.]

I can confirm this I have the uncommon warrior cat several times and got a 09 rare or more for it every time I traded it off. Plus, their 09 rare dogs are a few months older than yours, past the 3 month rule, so even that's overpay. Warrior cats in general have good demand so yeah, I'd go for it.

Thank you!

[|Lace|]

My auction for my full set of the '17 store lions has been going on for a long time and I only got 2 bids, but 1 got cancelled.
Should I just auto this bid? Or should I just wait for a better one to auto?

[MeowieCat]

thanks Cinder. for the last response

which one is fairer?or are none fair ?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SXxvQc15tA

OR

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rolD6dQvqg

[Fizzlebee]

?? my sister got a trade and was wondering if it was fair or not, please help if you can ty!

Very unfair to your sister. Her tess horse is worth a ton more. It's on the Rares List under the name "UR Mint Horse".

[Loki~Neith]

Fair or no? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GmMUzo_Sxw

[Goostarion]

My auction for my full set of the '17 store lions has been going on for a long time and I only got 2 bids, but 1 got cancelled.
Should I just auto this bid? Or should I just wait for a better one to auto?

This is more of a 'Is this a fiar trade?' thread, not really an advice for how you should run your auction thread. With that said, this trade is very unfair to them, as they are offering a lot of overpay for it.