The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Vega•]

Opinions on

1

AND

2

[Fwutter]

Opinions on

1

AND

2

I'm in sure about the second one, but the first one is highly unfair since they are trading you 2013-2016 rares for 2010-2012 rares. I think the 2009's are a fair enough swap, but the malks do have incredible demand and that '09 tan and blue dog is hard to trade away since it doesn't really have demand.

[the fool.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62893396&userid=314897&signature=Y-4cBpsVDf_FTZiOXYwd0g
Would this be fair to both of us? I'm not that great with pets that have demand.. At least I think the lioness has demand? Thanks in advance!

I'd say yes since the ghost cat is a low advent and july lionesses typically go for low/mid advents.
-snip-

Thank you! Can I get a second opinion?

[Fwutter]

Is this fair? Thank you!

Unfair to your trading partner already since the flower pot is way higher on the main list than the UR Bengal. Also from checking all the list multiple times I dont see that first dog anywhere on it.

Demand wise I would say you are overtrading. The flower pot doesn't really have great demand. The demand for an UR Bengal is way higher then demand for an UR flower part.

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62893396&userid=314897&signature=Y-4cBpsVDf_FTZiOXYwd0g
Would this be fair to both of us? I'm not that great with pets that have demand.. At least I think the lioness has demand? Thanks in advance!

I'd say yes since the ghost cat is a low advent and july lionesses typically go for low/mid advents.
-snip-

Thank you! Can I get a second opinion?

I do agree since the July lionesses does have higher demand then the ghost cat I would say yes this is fair! The ghost cat isn't a really easy pet to trade away so is any other advent tier 1 list pet. In conclusion this is a fair trade because yes a July lioness can go for a low/mid advent :)

[Lemon Feet]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62904626&userid=233638&signature=3E2k_zwYZJy8YZaOX1cMyA
I just received this trade, is it fair? Thank you in advance to anyone who helps. I've been gone for a while so I'm not sure about the worth of older pets anymore.

[waspinator]

how does this look? there's too many pets for me to understand easily,,
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62887699&userid=301187&signature=URZq_vtwWG12uDf1VNcVcw

also this one!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62904343&userid=301187&signature=iwN-L1EKgfOTMj-eaFVeRg

[watery>~<]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=4804123
What's this worth??

To waspinator: I'm not sure about the first one (cuz it's too confusing) but the second one is definitely worth it

[Halsie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62903784&userid=656194&signature=l1PKW5MTt5qGKguevgLO4Q

Is this fair for me? I'm not so good with trades that involve C$ and I want to get my pets worth. Also, would you accept this(if the list dog was yours)? Thanks!

A bottom tier advent is worth 55c$. So they are overpaying quite a bit. I'd take it. It's not that hard to get a bottom tier list pet back (:

Thanks! c: Can I get another opinion?

[juyeo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62903784&userid=656194&signature=l1PKW5MTt5qGKguevgLO4Q

Is this fair for me? I'm not so good with trades that involve C$ and I want to get my pets worth. Also, would you accept this(if the list dog was yours)? Thanks!

A bottom tier advent is worth 55c$. So they are overpaying quite a bit. I'd take it. It's not that hard to get a bottom tier list pet back (:

Thanks! c: Can I get another opinion?

It is overpay, but I wouldn't take it. Personally, I haven't run into many people who trade off list, and it takes a while to get on the list once your off it (if this is your only list idk). I also don't find c$ as valuable because not many people seem to want large amounts of it for valuable pets. But you're free to do whatever you please, especially if you think differently than me c: