The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Halsie]

would this be fair? thank you anyone in advance! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62892503&userid=764953&signature=eXey7NMoTozV4uEkhmocqQ

Unfair to the '13 Rare's side ^^

Disagree.
The tiger store pet is worth a 2010 rare and from what i see, the tigers (especially the pps) goes for pretty good trades so i don't think it'll be very hard to get a 2009 rare. But even with rarity, the 2013 rares side is worth a 2012 rare, which is 1/4 the amount the pps tiger is worth.

I agree with Shadow. PPS lions have a pretty high demand but not only that, it is a store pet and worth much more than that.

[Sinbreaker]

need opinions
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... burrbUPu4A

please include demand and trading value of both sides

[Shadow2204]

need opinions
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... burrbUPu4A

please include demand and trading value of both sides

Bee is worth 2 nons, the ur aussie is worth 1 non + a sorbet. Ravens usually go for around a sorbet I heard...Nons are kind of hard to get from a raven i'd say, that's too much overpay in my opinion. So valuing at a sorbet, it'd be worth 1 non + 2 sorbets so they're a sorbet short by rarity (assuming raven = sorbet)

[dddddonuts]

-link-

Does anyone know if this is fair demand wise?

[MeowieCat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lzUO1_dhWg

is this fair? demand wise as well

[luc]

Should I accept this offer?

It's pretty big overpay on their side. Your pet is worth a late '10 rare and they're offering a bit more than twice the value. I usually don't see a single recent store pet going for more than this

Thank you!

is this the best i can get for my pocky at auction?
Yes. The Pocky is worth an 08 rare or very rare, but they are offering even more. I suggest accept that.

Thank you. Any second opinions?

[the fool.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62893396&userid=314897&signature=Y-4cBpsVDf_FTZiOXYwd0g
Would this be fair to both of us? I'm not that great with pets that have demand.. At least I think the lioness has demand? Thanks in advance!

[Shadow2204]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62893396&userid=314897&signature=Y-4cBpsVDf_FTZiOXYwd0g
Would this be fair to both of us? I'm not that great with pets that have demand.. At least I think the lioness has demand? Thanks in advance!

I'd say yes since the ghost cat is a low advent and july lionesses typically go for low/mid advents.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62893199&userid=811292&signature=UiQpKNrIIY2slzUO1_dhWg

is this fair? demand wise as well

I'd say overpaying a lot even with demand.
I think the most the dragon would get would be a low advent and the basilisk may get maybe a tier 3 or so with demand. Grinner would be overpaying.
Try for a 2nd opinion though.

[Rain;;]

is this fair??
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tpDepabirQ

[Catsrock237]

What would a July lioness be worth..?