The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[rain,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8lEI5sf8FQ
What would need to be done to make this fair?

Since the pets were free, their rarity will most likely range from common-uncommon, so they need to add either a 2011 uncommon - 4 2016 uncommons.

[Kittycentral~]

May I ask for the current demand of the little cinnamon roll? Would a sorbet be a reasonable offer? ^^ I'd appreciate any feedback, thank you!

[Cell ii]

Blue ice rat(near the top of September list) for peppermint bun(Advent tier 3)? Rat seems like a hell of a lot overpay but I'm always sceptical about the low demand for rats. What has to be added to the bun side?

[rain,]

May I ask for the current demand of the little cinnamon roll? Would a sorbet be a reasonable offer? ^^ I'd appreciate any feedback, thank you!

It is very hard to tell demand and where the list placement is for the cinnamon roll, but if we value it the same as the UR Zonkey, then it should be worth about a non or a non and a low mainlist at the very least. A UR Zonkey would also be a fair swap.

[Shadow2204]

How does this look?

Am I able to get quantity back from the flower pot?
Thank you in advance!

[.crossfire.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8lEI5sf8FQ
What would need to be done to make this fair?

Since the pets were free, their rarity will most likely range from common-uncommon, so they need to add either a 2011 uncommon - 4 2016 uncommons.

actually, that's not true... the unknown rarity pets can range from common-rare.. in order to make it fair, they need to add at least an '09 common or a '10 uncommon

[wonderlandfox]

How does this look?

Am I able to get quantity back from the flower pot?
Thank you in advance!

Depending on who you're trading with you might be able to get quantity back.
I traded my flower pot once to somebody who really wanted it and I got decent quantity back.
It is up to you if you want to go through with the commitment of trading off the flower pot.
It can get frustrating when trading off such a low demand pet.
If you're willing to wait and take the time to get the quantity you want, then take it.
If you're not willing to wait, don't take it.

[_BlackWidow_]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62722006&userid=754849&signature=Rsi_BXkcED9ErxRle3g_Pw
Opinions? Demand wise?

[Shadow2204]

How does this look?

Am I able to get quantity back from the flower pot?
Thank you in advance!

Depending on who you're trading with you might be able to get quantity back.
I traded my flower pot once to somebody who really wanted it and I got decent quantity back.
It is up to you if you want to go through with the commitment of trading off the flower pot.
It can get frustrating when trading off such a low demand pet.
If you're willing to wait and take the time to get the quantity you want, then take it.
If you're not willing to wait, don't take it.

Thank you!
I'd like a 2nd opinion please c:

[.crossfire.]

How does this look?

Am I able to get quantity back from the flower pot?
Thank you in advance!

Depending on who you're trading with you might be able to get quantity back.
I traded my flower pot once to somebody who really wanted it and I got decent quantity back.
It is up to you if you want to go through with the commitment of trading off the flower pot.
It can get frustrating when trading off such a low demand pet.
If you're willing to wait and take the time to get the quantity you want, then take it.
If you're not willing to wait, don't take it.

Thank you!
I'd like a 2nd opinion please c:

i agree. If you put enough commitment into getting the quantity back, then you could get it with time. but that's if your willing to be patient for it. if you don't think you can wait, i wouldn't even bother accepting.