The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[.crossfire.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62888654&userid=440251&signature=aw36an4UE-weVtr9zJwWoQ

How fair would this be? I'd appreciate any help!

unfair to you. '16 store pets are worth mid-late '10 rare. About 3 of your pets equal the dog from'08. All my inform is off 'What is my Pet Worth' thread. Search Engine helps :3

Don't forget to get another opinion

[_BlackWidow_]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62887613&userid=754849&signature=WZrEPoDP_n89xNcAbBxhvw

Fair?

[polly pocket]

Opinions on this trade? x & this one x
Thank youu

The first one is very unfair to you. The ice rat is only a high september.

Thank you

[Wei]

XxXxX

Is the UR Flower Pot fair for my Sorbet and Sunjewel bunny, when keeping demand in mind?

[Charmander0]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Vtr9zJwWoQ

How fair would this be? I'd appreciate any help!

unfair to you. '16 store pets are worth mid-late '10 rare. About 3 of your pets equal the dog from'08. All my inform is off 'What is my Pet Worth' thread. Search Engine helps :3

Don't forget to get another opinion

Thank you, friend! That's very helpful!

Can I get a second opinion, please?

[Fizzlebee]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62888654&userid=440251&signature=aw36an4UE-weVtr9zJwWoQ

How fair would this be? I'd appreciate any help!

unfair to you. '16 store pets are worth mid-late '10 rare. About 3 of your pets equal the dog from'08. All my inform is off 'What is my Pet Worth' thread. Search Engine helps :3

Don't forget to get another opinion

I agree. Though the store horses are from 2015 not '16, making it even more unfair to you.

[Ranger of the North]

How does this look? c:

They are technically overpaying but demand wise the flower basically goes for a sorbet. But with patience you can get more!

Second opinion needed c:

For trade 1, yes it technically is overpay since the UR Pot's value is two sorbets and a green toxic if you don't consider demand. With demand it does tend to go lower, but you can certainly get more than just one sorbet for the UR Pot if you're willing to trade around.

Aaah, thank you so much! >^.^< <3

2

Taking the fact that C$ is pretty valuable to me (I don't have the money to buy it, so everything 'store' is off-limits otherwise :p) into account, is this fair? c:

For trade 2, sorbets are worth a dark leopard (top tier september) and a top tier mid august. The red dragon is only a bottom tier september. Even if you value the C$ more highly than usual, at say, a mid/low september, it would still be unfair to you. The store dragons do not make up much of that gap, especially since they just left the store. Note that this isn't taking into account the demand, so if you're wondering about that then definitely get more opinions.

Okay, thank you so much! <3
Could I please get a second opinion? c:

3

Kia ora!
Is this fair?
Thanks so, so much for any help! <3

Opinions? c: C$ is more valuable to me than usual, btw; I can't buy it, so everything 'store' is basically off-limits otherwise c:

[dddddonuts]

Would this be fair for my raven dog in terms of demand? I'm really very iffy on trading it off. I realize this is probably overpay on their side but as I took a 1.5 year semi-hiatus I'd like to get some opinions because I'm a little rusty.

Edit: Please do not offer for the raven dog or any of my singles. I had only considered this trade because it had a large quantity of rarer wishlist pets which would've contributed more to the completion of my collection. This does not mean that I am suddenly trading my singles. I have gotten 8 trades for the raven dog since I posted this.

[.crossfire.]

@fizzlebee sorry that was a typo}
@anyone,
Can you get a nick dog with a beta fish if the dog was released in August 2009, and the beta in September?

[luc]

Should I accept this offer?

It's pretty big overpay on their side. Your pet is worth a late '10 rare and they're offering a bit more than twice the value. I usually don't see a single recent store pet going for more than this

Thank you!

is this the best i can get for my pocky at auction?