The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[paria.]

Is this a fair trade?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62854776&userid=807547&signature=f1Ug30RBDV_HrG4i7vS9PA

[marimba]

is this fair?

[Pinesong]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62853663&userid=855492&signature=zMavKjx2sLZ_-y3B5TfPnw

Is this trade fair? The pet is a rerelease from 2009

[BBkat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FohW1XzBfA

How about this one?

This is the wrong kind of link. When viewing the trade, click [Share Trade] right beside the message on the top of the page

? The link works fine. It was just touching the ']' for the quoted text. When it does that it becomes unclickable(but if you copy+paste it it works fine)

[non]

Is this a fair trade?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62854776&userid=807547&signature=f1Ug30RBDV_HrG4i7vS9PA

Yes c: in fact it's a little overpay on their side! your pet is worth a tier six + around an o9 rare or two. they're offering a tier six, plus a 2009 + 2010 rare and a 2010 uncommon, so it's more than fair, although bunnies are pretty hard to trade off.

[Pinesong]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -y3B5TfPnw

Is this trade fair? The pet is a rerelease from 2009

[Katskatskats]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62853721&userid=825453&signature=EDy44jTw0lpBDbM0hSuO1w
is this fair for my non balloon dog? I dont know.

[luc]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62846459&userid=559651&signature=_QJzGtAupPbZrtQ8DWP5kg

is this fair? :)

[marimba]

is this fair?

So let's see, the DIY Cake set is worth about a sorbet but people tend to pay more for it, varying on who you trade with but let's just say a sorbet since it's easier without playing with demand. The animal egg can go for a couple 09 rares to probably a mid advent list, depending on who you trade with as well. The Pocky is worth an 09 rare, but can go for more depending on who you trade with as well. It would be unfair to you, rarity wise since your pet is worth 2 Sorbets and they are offering about a sorbet+a low advent?

Demand comes into play as well. The DIY Cake set you could only get if you entered an acceptable cake for the Cake Contest. Lots of people traded away their individual pieces, so there are few left as a set. But I think someone did a poll and not many people were seeking the set, but I've seen item collectors pay a lot for the set. Recently, I believe I saw someone pay a UR Bee for the set, excluding the candles and the candy. But it just depends if you want the set or not. The Pocky can fetch a mid advent if you find the right person, as well. The Animal Egg 4, there aren't many in circulation, maybe about 50? I've come across that are actually in circulation, but I've also come across a lot of users who just won't trade theirs. So the Animal Egg can go for lists if you find the right person. It just depends if you like items or not. The BEG can fetch a non+ if you find the right person as well. So let's just say the DIY Cake set is worth about 1-2 nons "demand wise". Then that would mean that they are overpaying by about a sorbet-a non, depending on how much you value those items with their "Demand".

Honestly, I wouldn't accept the trade since I already own those items and I'm an item collector. But let's say I didn't own those items, I still wouldn't accept since I don't really like the majority of trades to be items.

Thank you so much! ^u^

[Starlight~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lbvrIzVHFo

sorry guys heres the link