The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Kitty Cheshire]

Hi!
Please help me!
Is this fair: Strawberry PPS (on their side) for Lilac Dutch bunny (on my side)?
This for this
Thank you!

Unfair to you. The strawberry PPS is just an 09 very rare whereas the lilac bun is a tier 1 c;

[Sergeant Winter]

Hi!
Please help me!
Is this fair: Strawberry PPS (on their side) for Lilac Dutch bunny (on my side)?
This for this
Thank you!

Unfair to you. The strawberry PPS is just an 09 very rare whereas the lilac bun is a tier 1 c;

Thank you!
But in "the rares list guide" there are only black and gray dutch bunny, so I thought my bunny isn't List pet

[princess]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62799280&userid=728858&signature=mTiQFhSlBv7EYnLzPyAuiA
A bid on my auction- I mean I don't find it very fair but a second opinion is always nice!
This is what they said:

"I know this isn't fair in terms of rarities, but in my mind the dragon is worth more in terms of demand. (Also because it's newer)
So, uh... Yeah."

[princess]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62799280&userid=728858&signature=mTiQFhSlBv7EYnLzPyAuiA
A bid on my auction- I mean I don't find it very fair but a second opinion is always nice!
This is what they said:

"I know this isn't fair in terms of rarities, but in my mind the dragon is worth more in terms of demand. (Also because it's newer)
So, uh... Yeah."

Very unfair to you. Both llamas would be worth about 2 09 rares, in my value and their pet is only worth one '10 rare. If the dragon is newer, that means it's worth less. Definitely wouldn't accept this bid

Thank you for confirming my previous thoughts, I just didn't want to be rude to the bidder!

[Pastelaj]

Opinions on this please?
And this please?
Oh and this?

[LostForever]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62799280&userid=728858&signature=mTiQFhSlBv7EYnLzPyAuiA
A bid on my auction- I mean I don't find it very fair but a second opinion is always nice!
This is what they said:

"I know this isn't fair in terms of rarities, but in my mind the dragon is worth more in terms of demand. (Also because it's newer)
So, uh... Yeah."

Thats not how it works, newer pets are worth less than older pets, i would definatly cancel this bid

[lil rascal]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62779198&userid=58742&signature=0FINSvHyZ15kfMdDozm6vQ
I know its not fair just yet, but I have no idea how much more to ask for? Might remove those common and very commons to just clean up the trade.
They have an Xmas '12 very rare, but other than that there's just a '15 rare and kinda basic pets after that. Any point continuing to negotiate?

The Christmas '12 VR you mentioned would be a re-release or store pet as there were no normal adopt Christmas '12 VR's, so it would be unfair to them for your uncommon. I'm not great at rarity math across such a big age gap so can't really help with what to add, sorry.

Hi!
Please help me!
Is this fair: Strawberry PPS (on their side) for Lilac Dutch bunny (on my side)?
This for this
Thank you!

Unfair to you. The strawberry PPS is just an 09 very rare whereas the lilac bun is a tier 1 c;

Thank you!
But in "the rares list guide" there are only black and gray dutch bunny, so I thought my bunny isn't List pet

The first tier advent lilac bun is the solid lilac bun, the lilac dutch bun is not on the list & would be fair for the strawberry pps. If you're ever in doubt you can check page 2 & 3 of the rares list, which has the picture versions of the lists

[Light Bringer]

Hi there, is this fair? Thanks to whoever can answer.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BcdRLiiDKA

[leiawolfe]

UR peach=Pocky item?

Ty

[lil rascal]

Hi there, is this fair? Thanks to whoever can answer.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BcdRLiiDKA

Very unfair to you, the Gryphon Store Set is still in the store for 17C$ for the set of 4 pieces, which would make the wings worth about 4-5C$. Just your early '09 rare is worth 40-45C$, let alone all the other pets.

UR peach=Pocky item?

Ty

Very unfair to the UR peach. The Pocky item is listed as being worth a normal (non-list) '08 rare/VR on the items list. The items list is in need of an update & the pocky often goes for a lot more than a normal '08 rare/VR value but no where near UR Peach value, which, even though it hasn't been placed on the list yet, is worth a main list