The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Oshawott8888]

Thanks everyone for your responses ^^

[Oshawott8888]

Quite unexpectedly I have gotten many trades (some of which I cancelled) on first animal eggs. I have not been looking to trade them, but I would want to know if any of these trades are good....or if any of them are so bad, that I better cancel them right now. I know first 4 animal eggs are worth quite a lot and have been going up in value, but I don't know how much are they really worth (item list seems to be somewhat outdated on that issue). I hope to hear from those who actually have some old item value knowledge.
1st trade
2nd trade
3rd trade
trade 4
and 5th
edit: sorry, they keep pouring in (like it's some kind of competition ), when I just need advice

still need help

Can someone tell us about the 5th trade at least? I am on the other side. <:

I checked the items list guide, and it seems like the 3 animal eggs are worth approximately a late 08 rare/vr
The items guide hasn't been updated recently, so I'm going to assume they'll go for double the worth, if that's ok
So that's around anywhere from 12 09 rares to 24
I think that's around a low to mid Sept list?
Most of this is just guessing, so correct me if I'm wrong XD


Anyways, the ur malk would be extreme overpay in any way you look at it

Especially since many people value it at a non I think?

[NzuriMoyo]

Quite unexpectedly I have gotten many trades (some of which I cancelled) on first animal eggs. I have not been looking to trade them, but I would want to know if any of these trades are good....or if any of them are so bad, that I better cancel them right now. I know first 4 animal eggs are worth quite a lot and have been going up in value, but I don't know how much are they really worth (item list seems to be somewhat outdated on that issue). I hope to hear from those who actually have some old item value knowledge.
1st trade
2nd trade
3rd trade
trade 4
and 5th
edit: sorry, they keep pouring in (like it's some kind of competition ), when I just need advice

still need help

Can someone tell us about the 5th trade at least? I am on the other side. <:

From checking the items guide each egg is worth a 08 rare/very rare. Meaning the UR malk dog is extreme overpay for them.

[עורב לבן]

This person wants to work out a trade. I told them it wasn't fair to me, but that I would see what we could do to fix it.

Thank you so much in advance!

A 2012 store pet is worth about an early-mid 09 rare. I tend to do 2:1 when working out rare worth of previous years but other people may have different systems. They do need to add some more though, either quantity recent rares or something a bit older.

Thank you again!

[Rose5335]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ru99xiysfw

Thanks for the help!

[SteampunkAngel]

edit: unsure

[QuirkCirc]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fdTFkg76jQ

Sorry for bothering you guys again but I was wondering if this is fair for both me and the other party. I'm not sure how much an '09 malk is worth in items

[Bloodpaw/Sangre]

Thank you Oshawott8888 & Spraybottle12 for help on the other trade :3


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cw2PpvM2yA

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aaqA_pTMGQ

I'd love some help with these trades
Thank you in advance

[Cynical Comedian]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ru99xiysfw

Thanks for the help!

I'd say it's fair. The rainbow dogs have decent demand and the other commons and uncommons on thier side should even out the dispute over your pet's demand. But that's my edcuated opinion on the matter. I know your pet has quite a bit demand, but the trade seems fair considering everything.

[NzuriMoyo]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ru99xiysfw

Thanks for the help!

I'd say it's fair. The rainbow dogs have decent demand and the other commons and uncommons on thier side should even out the dispute over your pet's demand. But that's my edcuated opinion on the matter. I know your pet has quite a bit demand, but the trade seems fair considering everything.

Agreed it was fair if not even a little overpay on their side. The dogs are within the three month rule and the Aussie pps dogs have decent demand as do the rainbow dogs. Them just offering the rainbow dog for the Aussie pps would of been fair so they would be overpaying with the uncommons they added