The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[LostForever]

Heya!
I'm having an auction for the recent store lions and I got this bid.
Personally I think it's pretty decent, considering they did include an advent, and usually a set of 4 stores can get you a low advent.
But I would like a second opinion, as I have been told I am wrong?
TIA for the help if I forget!

That is a great bid, personally i would auto it as the advent list is a tier 7 (i think)

[ThunderCedar]

Heya!
I'm having an auction for the recent store lions and I got this bid.
Personally I think it's pretty decent, considering they did include an advent, and usually a set of 4 stores can get you a low advent.
But I would like a second opinion, as I have been told I am wrong?
TIA for the help if I forget!

Very unfair to them, your pets are still available to buy in the store and are worth a late 09 rare together. Even with demand, their mid advent is worth way more. It's pretty wanted. It's a tier 7. Huge overpay on their part.
I didn't have to pay nearly as much for my lion set.

[Oshawott8888]

Just wondering, why do t7 advents have more demand than other advents? sorry if this doesnt belong here ;-;

[Rose5335]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ru99xiysfw

Thanks for the help!

[LostForever]

Just wondering, why do t7 advents have more demand than other advents? sorry if this doesnt belong here ;-;

I dont think its all of them, just some of the are very wanted designs and ones like the raven dog dont get re-released

[ThunderCedar]

Just wondering, why do t7 advents have more demand than other advents? sorry if this doesnt belong here ;-;

Most T7 adult dogs are from the original CS release. Before CS wad the way it is now, you used to be able to just put images of pets in your signature on other websites. It was completely different. It was a kennels website and the pets available were mostly the T7 ones today. Cookie dogs, huskies .. etc. That's part of the reason. Also people just tend to hoard them more. For example I hoard blue flowerflakes. My friends hoard: brown cookie dogs. Purple heart/huskies. Pink cookie dogs. Grey speckled huskies.
And of course, most importantly, like all things: demand mostly comes from looks. They look pretty.

[lil rascal]

Is this fair?? thanks for the help!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ToWkidt4SQ

Unfair demand wise to them, and Firestar is originally from '08 so it's also unfair rarity wise

no its not, both are rares, and the firestar is a remake from 2016... the malk fox is from 2010

no, firestar is a rerelease from 08,
and also warriors go for overpay
so the side with the malk wolf from 2009 i think? would be underpaying

Personally I disagree.
The cat is a re-release from '08 but they were extended release pets available until August '09 so are considered to be worth an '09, the wolf is a re-release from November '09. Both warrior cats & Malk wolves have good demand & can go for overpay so I'd say it is fair both rarity & demand wise

You can read about extended releases here viewtopic.php?f=20&t=1812615#p56153545

Just wondering, why do t7 advents have more demand than other advents? sorry if this doesnt belong here ;-;

I think it's partly due to the design of some of the tier 7s & partly because gaps on the lower parts of the list tend to be measured by mid-advents. It's a little like sorbets, they actually didn't used to have amazing demand but once they became a measure for jumping up the list they became much more popular.

[hellhunt]

Quite unexpectedly I have gotten many trades (some of which I cancelled) on first animal eggs. I have not been looking to trade them, but I would want to know if any of these trades are good....or if any of them are so bad, that I better cancel them right now. I know first 4 animal eggs are worth quite a lot and have been going up in value, but I don't know how much are they really worth (item list seems to be somewhat outdated on that issue). I hope to hear from those who actually have some old item value knowledge.
1st trade
2nd trade
3rd trade
trade 4
and 5th
edit: sorry, they keep pouring in (like it's some kind of competition ), when I just need advice

still need help

[ThunderCedar]

Quite unexpectedly I have gotten many trades (some of which I cancelled) on first animal eggs. I have not been looking to trade them, but I would want to know if any of these trades are good....or if any of them are so bad, that I better cancel them right now. I know first 4 animal eggs are worth quite a lot and have been going up in value, but I don't know how much are they really worth (item list seems to be somewhat outdated on that issue). I hope to hear from those who actually have some old item value knowledge.
1st trade
2nd trade
3rd trade
trade 4
and 5th
edit: sorry, they keep pouring in (like it's some kind of competition ), when I just need advice

still need help

Can someone tell us about the 5th trade at least? I am on the other side. <:

[Bilbo]

Quite unexpectedly I have gotten many trades (some of which I cancelled) on first animal eggs. I have not been looking to trade them, but I would want to know if any of these trades are good....or if any of them are so bad, that I better cancel them right now. I know first 4 animal eggs are worth quite a lot and have been going up in value, but I don't know how much are they really worth (item list seems to be somewhat outdated on that issue). I hope to hear from those who actually have some old item value knowledge.
1st trade
2nd trade
3rd trade
trade 4
and 5th
edit: sorry, they keep pouring in (like it's some kind of competition ), when I just need advice

still need help

Can someone tell us about the 5th trade at least? I am on the other side. <:

I'm not completely sure of the value of these eggs are, but in case you're looking for which trade is currently offering you the most, the fifth trade blows all of the others out of the water when it comes to value.