The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Shadow2204]

Are any of these fair? What do i need to add/remove?

I feel like these items go for overpay

Not sure what the recent animal eggs go for

[Bloodpaw/Sangre]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cw2PpvM2yA

I'd love some help with this trade
Thank you in advance

[AdamJ]

Is this fair?? thanks for the help!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ToWkidt4SQ

Unfair demand wise to them, and Firestar is originally from '08 so it's also unfair rarity wise

no its not, both are rares, and the firestar is a remake from 2016... the malk fox is from 2010

[Oshawott8888]

]http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62771320&userid=548495&signature=QozqfpalGAUfcw2PpvM2yA

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rdDKaPnRBQ

I'd love some help with these trades
Thank you in advance

i'm not too sure about the first one, but for the second one, you'd be overpaying, since i believe the ur aussie is super hard to trade off or something? and the ur lion and ur bengal have generally pretty good demand


i think the ur aussie goes for around a non at most?
'correct me if i'm wrong ^^

[Oshawott8888]

Is this fair?? thanks for the help!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ToWkidt4SQ

Unfair demand wise to them, and Firestar is originally from '08 so it's also unfair rarity wise

no its not, both are rares, and the firestar is a remake from 2016... the malk fox is from 2010

no, firestar is a rerelease from 08,
and also warriors go for overpay
so the side with the malk wolf from 2009 i think? would be underpaying

[ThunderCedar]

Are any of these fair? What do i need to add/remove?

I feel like these items go for overpay

Not sure what the recent animal eggs go for

The first trade is technically unfair to them because the white dragon is worth a 2011 uncommon so a 2012 rare is twice the price
I have seen the white dragon go for a 2011 rare a few times though
And as for the 2nd trade, animal eggs are worth about an uncommon token pet from their event. Some will pay more, but that really depends on the person

[ShadowStride]

Heya!
I'm having an auction for the recent store lions and I got this bid.
Personally I think it's pretty decent, considering they did include an advent, and usually a set of 4 stores can get you a low advent.
But I would like a second opinion, as I have been told I am wrong?
TIA for the help if I forget!

[LostForever]

Is this fair?? thanks for the help!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ToWkidt4SQ

Unfair demand wise to them, and Firestar is originally from '08 so it's also unfair rarity wise

no its not, both are rares, and the firestar is a remake from 2016... the malk fox is from 2010

The fire star is a re- release from 2008 meaning that it is very unfair to the cat, just because it was re-released in 2016 does not change it value, so the first person is right.

[Shadow2204]

Are any of these fair? What do i need to add/remove?

I feel like these items go for overpay

Not sure what the recent animal eggs go for

The first trade is technically unfair to them because the white dragon is worth a 2011 uncommon so a 2012 rare is twice the price
I have seen the white dragon go for a 2011 rare a few times though
And as for the 2nd trade, animal eggs are worth about an uncommon token pet from their event. Some will pay more, but that really depends on the person

Thank you! (oops, didn't see it the first time)

[Elettra]

]http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62771320&userid=548495&signature=QozqfpalGAUfcw2PpvM2yA

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rdDKaPnRBQ

I'd love some help with these trades
Thank you in advance

i'm not too sure about the first one, but for the second one, you'd be overpaying, since i believe the ur aussie is super hard to trade off or something? and the ur lion and ur bengal have generally pretty good demand


i think the ur aussie goes for around a non at most?
'correct me if i'm wrong ^^

Demand wise, I agree. Personally, I wouldn't accept. I had an aussie, and the most I could trade it off for was a non + a skele PPS. It took awhile to trade off though. The UR Lion and bengal both have very good demand. I was able to trade my UR lion quite easily. Hope that helps!