The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Firestar6]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62370557&userid=726302&signature=WiOKQwHwgSKhDZSfr0VTpg
is this fair??

[basicbassoonist]

how fair is this bid?

warning: it's a bid for ALL 54 pages of my items (minus my event tokens and animal eggs from this easter)

[Charmander0]

tore Pets
Is this fair? I think I am underpaying but who knows?

Sauces

I wouldn't necessarily think they're underpaying. They might even be overpaying! I would like an opinion on this too though, please!

[Jiloon]

They're obviously overpaying rarity wise, but could I get a little more demand wise? The Dark Grey Tag Husky has decent demand, but I'm looking to trade upwards, and I'm not sure if it's the best choice for that?

Clicky

Thanks for any help!

[Kyar]

tore Pets
Is this fair? I think I am underpaying but who knows?

Sauces

I wouldn't necessarily think they're underpaying. They might even be overpaying! I would like an opinion on this too though, please!

I'd say unfair to the gray dog in terms of rarity - that's a mid 09 rare and the 2014 store pets value wise are worth right in the early 10-maybe a late 09 rare range. :) So I'd say yeah the store pet could do to add a little. Probably in the area of a couple 2010 uncommons or so.

Edit:

They're obviously overpaying rarity wise, but could I get a little more demand wise? The Dark Grey Tag Husky has decent demand, but I'm looking to trade upwards, and I'm not sure if it's the best choice for that?

Clicky

Thanks for any help!

I haven't seen a ton of android trades recently but honestly even with the crazy store pet demand trend as of late - the androids never went for a ton and rarity wise that's pretty decent overpay. The gray tag isn't in CRAZY high demand but mid advent dogs are always popular/and easy trade/great fodder. :) So that looks plenty reasonable to me!

[Kabuski]

Is this fair? What are my items worth?

[Tamriel]

What should be added?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kZa_stEA8A

[NzuriMoyo]

Thank you for the replies! Now does this add up to a mid September for the 08 halo?

[Jiloon]

Edit:

They're obviously overpaying rarity wise, but could I get a little more demand wise? The Dark Grey Tag Husky has decent demand, but I'm looking to trade upwards, and I'm not sure if it's the best choice for that?

Clicky

Thanks for any help!

I haven't seen a ton of android trades recently but honestly even with the crazy store pet demand trend as of late - the androids never went for a ton and rarity wise that's pretty decent overpay. The gray tag isn't in CRAZY high demand but mid advent dogs are always popular/and easy trade/great fodder. So that looks plenty reasonable to me!

Thanks for the input! Pretty much what I was thinking, it's just that the Red Android is currently my sole List pet to trade, and I need to go up xD

Could I perhaps get one or two more answers?

[|Cornelius|]

I need help figuring out witch trade would be the best to take rarity and demand wise
trade 1
trade 2
trade 3