The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[employer]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62270340&userid=842198&signature=VVyiXD1lyDVkN4S45HlJ1A
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8tVqkdZz7Q
I'm not sure with these two, help please?

im pretty sure they are pretty fair...................... but maybe take advice from someone else cuz well i dont know but my opinion they are very fair

Alright, thanks! Could I maybe get a second opinion too?

[Rini]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62270340&userid=842198&signature=VVyiXD1lyDVkN4S45HlJ1A
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8tVqkdZz7Q
I'm not sure with these two, help please?

im pretty sure they are pretty fair...................... but maybe take advice from someone else cuz well i dont know but my opinion they are very fair

Alright, thanks! Could I maybe get a second opinion too?

Yep, they both check out with me, too.

[doge fruit]

would this be fair for tokens?

[$crim]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62270340&userid=842198&signature=VVyiXD1lyDVkN4S45HlJ1A
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8tVqkdZz7Q
I'm not sure with these two, help please?

im pretty sure they are pretty fair...................... but maybe take advice from someone else cuz well i dont know but my opinion they are very fair

Alright, thanks! Could I maybe get a second opinion too?

I believe they're overtrading due to the fact the rat they're offering is worth two early 2009 rares and they're only asking for one 2009 rare from you.

[Kabuski]

Is this fair?

[Rini]

Is this fair, rarity & demand wise?
Edit: and this one too?
Gifting the first two to provide a good answer <3 thank you in advance!

[Rini]

Is this fair?

I would say they're underpaying a bit.

[Horror]

Is this fair?

I think it's a little unfair to you^^
The bunny is enough for the horse store pet & the rest doesn't add up to equal another 09 rare + '10 rare

[C_E_Lover]

I recently received this trade, is this fair? I'm usually good with determining but with rares, rereleases and dates I am not so good. The draftie is from Valentine's 2010 clicky
Thanks for any and all advice!

With the cheese hat, it looks unfair to you by 2-3 more '11 uncommons if not an early '11 rare
It's kinda hard to tell with items like that, one not well circulated and also not posted on item threads for proof

Okay thank you! Any second opinions?

[juyeo]

Hi! So, I'm currently holding an auction for both Hollyleaf and Brightheart, so I was wondering which bid was the best?
Bid for Brightheart + Bid for Hollyleaf
or
Bid for Both
or
Bid for Both
Any help is appreciated, and if I could get several opinions that would be great!

I would pick the first bid for both because most of these bid one 2009 rare for each cat but this one bid a 2009 rare and a malk elemental cat (high demand)

Get a second opinion to be sure

I also lean towards the first bid for both, mostly because of the Malk elemental. Almost no one is willing to trade theirs away, and they have quite high demand. The mermaid items are also pretty good.

Thank you both very very much!