The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[CatherineTheCat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VrT9CSYx0w
from all of these list pets, If i had to choose which one would be the fairest for the Rose dog?

[Keytone]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62242333&userid=781977&signature=zvNdAypm6fEpzLWmydDNXQ

fair or not

Please don't quote your post on the same page!

Your stars + earrings are Store items worth 12c$ in the store as a full set, and you've got about half of it here so I'd value what's in the trade at around 6$, the match is from November '11 and worth around a 3 month common/uncommon, the ink splatters are from Valentines Day '12 and is worth around 3 month common/uncommon as well, the locket is from the Beach Event '12 and is worth around an uncommon from the event or 3 months. The common/uncommon comes from your own personal evaluation of the items as some people will value them higher than others, although I'd lean towards uncommon with the age.

So from their side, 1 '11 uncommon would be for the match and 2 that overpay a bit for the other two non-store items, and most people value '10 uncommons around at 5-7C$ each, so I believe this would be overpay on their end since one of the '10 would be fair to the store items. So overall, at least on how I'd value all of it, this would be overpay for them!

[snowdrake]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62243145&userid=664384&signature=ybOL1LeUXRcEVrT9CSYx0w
from all of these list pets, If i had to choose which one would be the fairest for the Rose dog?

purely rarity-wise the fairest would be the pink september + christmas tree dog + 09 rare, though both of these pets have bad demand, especially the pink september. I'd say let them remove the pink september and add something worth around 6 '09 rares to make it fair. In list pets that'd be another tier 4/5 advent.

[kiono]

is it fair?

[Faybelline]

I don't trade list pets very often, and even less often item bulk of this caliber.
*warning, very item heavy*
If this fair? Or unfair to either side?

Any feedback would be just lovely!

[Gottheart]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4r9W7EUcoA
Not great with year gaps, would this actually be fair?

[regulus black]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62244232&userid=164063&signature=kcU_r3O4hmTu4r9W7EUcoA
Not great with year gaps, would this actually be fair?

Their side is worth 5 09 rares while yours is worth 4 - they are overpaying by one 09 rare c:

[Gottheart]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62244232&userid=164063&signature=kcU_r3O4hmTu4r9W7EUcoA
Not great with year gaps, would this actually be fair?

Their side is worth 5 09 rares while yours is worth 4 - they are overpaying by one 09 rare c:

Alright thanks

[saint]

is it fair?

Very unfair to them.
The Tess Horse is a re-release from 2008 so one of the store pets would be fine^^

[regulus black]

is it fair?

Very unfair to them.
The Tess Horse is a re-release from 2008 so one of the store pets would be fine^^

Actually, no.

One of the store pets would equal a mid/late 2010 rare, so that's not true. Four of them equal a mid/late 2008 rare. So the four store pets would be enough c: