The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Jiloon]

Hello!
I'm looking for advice on these two trades.

Clicky 1, Clicky 2

I know the second trade is obviously worth more rarity wise, but if they're offering it for such a low value, does that mean that the UR Purple Horse has bad enough demand that it's not really worth it? And I really like the Red-X dog, but will I be able to trade up with it, or down and then up? Thanks for any help!

[~GirlsDeMo~]

Hello!
I'm looking for advice on these two trades.

Clicky 1, Clicky 2

I know the second trade is obviously worth more rarity wise, but if they're offering it for such a low value, does that mean that the UR Purple Horse has bad enough demand that it's not really worth it? And I really like the Red-X dog, but will I be able to trade up with it, or down and then up? Thanks for any help!

"Clicky 1" Doesn't work, make sure to use the link given by the [Share Trade].

[saeko]

Trade 1
Trade 2

Are these trades fair or unfair? I'm still a newb at trading, so it would be awesome if you guys could help me before I possibly make a bad decision.

EDIT: Person from Trade 2 sent another trade here. Is this one fair?
So many questions

[~GirlsDeMo~]

How is Ravenpaw's demand compared to other Warriors?

[piggie]

How's this demand wise? Thanks!

rarity wise, it's a perfect fair swap but demand wise I'm not really sure but I've heard the non-tag is supposedly harder to trade off. I recommend getting a second opinion though.

Thank you! A second opinion on this, please?

[rainfall.]

would you accept this? i'm not too sure what the cinnamon roll is going for currently, but i guess i value it around a non? it's one of my main dreamies, but so is the coontail and i'm very attached to it since i got it from dec 18th adopts. i've heard the tribal (i think that's what it's called) has not so good demand, but what about the malk dragon?
please may i have more than one opinion? thank you ♥

[ingenuity,]

Hello!
I was wondering if this is fair?
I am terrible at item trades.
Thanks so much <3

I tried to get a reply before they cancelled, but it was too late.
I would still like to know if it was fair, just for my knowledge.
Thank you.

[its_loki]

hello!
i'd very much like some opinions on this trade, please! i'm quite conflicted, but i don't want to leave these players handing, so i'd very much appreciate some advice (:
thank you all in advance!

edit:
i'd gotten another offer after posting here, so i'd also like some opinions on this one, too, please!
thank you!

[Slumber]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kTm8cOqP-w

Is this fair?
If it is NOT what should be added or removed?

[pigeon -]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61667053&userid=745813&signature=IJ3v7NQ-rr_PkTm8cOqP-w

Is this fair?
If it is NOT what should be added or removed?

this is unfair to the store pet side as the store is worth a late '10 rare c:

to make it fair, if you value the malk at it's face value [ 10 uncommon ]
and a rare = 4 uncommons, you'd need three more '10 uncommons and
remove the '12 common from their side, feel free to get a second opinion!