The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[piggie]

Hey, it's me again... lol.
I need some help with this trade.
By the way, how is the demand of the UR B-Wolf? Thanks so much!

[regulus black]

I have a few trades including some older (non-list) store pets c:

would you personally accept? why/why not?

trade 1

trade 2

trade 3

thank you <3

[Eagle's Eye]

can i get help on this trade? c:

I'm not sure that I agree. One of your uncommons is a '10 rerelease. It looks unfair to you, though I'm unsure by how much.

actually, to hop in on the discussion here, the first 2010 dog isn't a rerelease.
it was part of the advent calendar. hope this helps! :]

they mean the second dog c:
could anyone let me know what would need changing?
i'm rubbish at trying to work out different years x.x

If I counted correctly, the top is worth roughly 14 2013 commons. So that'd be 7 2012 commons. Two 2010 uncommons alone would be worth 2 2012 rares or 8 2012 uncommons. Unfair to you

[n o k i a.]

Hey, it's me again... lol.
I need some help with this trade.
By the way, how is the demand of the UR B-Wolf? Thanks so much!

i personally wouldn't take it as the ur bwolf has quite low demand and is
difficult to trade off. though, with patience, you could get up to 2 nons
with demand, at least from what ive seen. i had a ur bwolf a little while
ago, and traded it for a little over a non. hope this helps! :]

[Eagle's Eye]

I have a few trades including some older (non-list) store pets c:

would you personally accept? why/why not?

trade 1

trade 2

trade 3

thank you <3

The first trade does look very tempting, but I wouldn't accept because I'm a collector and it's a pain to find older store pets
Second trade: I don't believe their very rare dog has any special demand (but please correct me if I'm wrong) but this is unfair to you value wise. 2013 store pet=late 2009 rare, 2014 store pet=early 2010 rare. With a little bit of overpay, these two alone could go for a late 2009 very rare
I wouldn't take the third trade, since it's very hard to trade back a 2011 store pet using 40C$.

[piggie]

Hey, it's me again... lol.
I need some help with this trade.
By the way, how is the demand of the UR B-Wolf? Thanks so much!

i personally wouldn't take it as the ur bwolf has quite low demand and is
difficult to trade off. though, with patience, you could get up to 2 nons
with demand, at least from what ive seen. i had a ur bwolf a little while
ago, and traded it for a little over a non. hope this helps! :]

Ah, thank you. A second opinion on this?

[hide]

hello! just wondering if this trade is fair or not. please tell me what needs to be added or changed, if possible. thanks in advance!

[Jiloon]

Hello!
I'm looking for advice on these two trades.

Clicky 1, Clicky 2

I know the second trade is obviously worth more rarity wise, but if they're offering it for such a low value, does that mean that the UR Purple Horse has bad enough demand that it's not really worth it? And I really like the Red-X dog, but will I be able to trade up with it, or down and then up? Thanks for any help!

[Kitty Cheshire]

hello! just wondering if this trade is fair or not. please tell me what needs to be added or changed, if possible. thanks in advance!

unfair to you. The grapes are a mainlist pet and the unicorn, pocket and even the c$ are still very unfair. The grapes is worth around 765c$.

[n o k i a.]

hello! just wondering if this trade is fair or not. please tell me what needs to be added or changed, if possible. thanks in advance!

this is quite unfair to you, though, im not sure what
should be added. hope this helps, though! :]