The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[kököchin]

Currently trying to decide a winner for an auction I've been hosting.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61436779&userid=834708&signature=cuJXMBebygpYr3ha5UQsdw

I like the quantity and number of wishlist pets in this one.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61479825&userid=834708&signature=tJrCG320CMAiNOs4hUA1Sg

This one is technically higher on the rares list than my auto win.

Any thoughts?

The first trade hardly breaches September list, and once you get on above the gap you're calculating pets in the 100s of advents in value between them sometimes.

Your non coon is worth about 240 advents, the first trade gets maybe 2.5 advents (Low Sept. list)- being VERY generous to the non 09 rares (the year gaps are somewhat exponential in nature, so most anything not in the 2009-2010 years is basically nothing when you trade by multi-09 values ^^;; I just rounded up for brevity.)

The second is pretty straightforward overpay. I'd take it, but that's because I really like the UR B-wolf >w< I think it's pretty. (I admit my bias)

I agree about the second trade- the bwolf doesn't have great demand but can still fetch more than a non. I'd take it.

I agree with all the statements above. The bwolf does have what you can say 'horrid' demand but at the least you can get a non (which is what you have) and at the most you can get two! So they're overpaying by quite a bit!

[NzuriMoyo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61631005&userid=504121&signature=NUdTfSBkb_KM0re6LAlAUA

would this be fair? Warning: there are 1457 items on one side (08 halo, fairies, etc) for one mainlist pet on the other side!
if it isn't fair could anyone tell me what would need to be added/removed to make it fair? thank you!

[far]

Is this fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61638268&userid=631842&signature=axhfhScrYrrgIoKjjqHMtA

The Blue swirl is 7-8 09 rares, and the Darkwood would be 3-4, roughly, so it looks good =3

Thanks second opinion?

[hide]

hello, i'm back again. wondering if this trade is fair. thanks in advance!

[.naiad.]

hello, i'm back again. wondering if this trade is fair. thanks in advance!

Unfair to the joker. The other side isn't worth as much because the September list doesnt have great demand, and rarity wise isn't near the joker - the cat doesn't make up the gap because, even though it has good demand, it has dies down recently.

[pigeon -]

i'm trying to trade my sorbet down for some quantity ; how does this look? c:

Pretty close by Mainlist standards, actually. Still unfair to the Sorbet by about 34 Mid-advents so roughly another Nonballoon or a few good Septembers, but you could ballpark it depending on your partner. =3

thank you! could i get another opinion as well? c:

[hide]

my apologies for posting here more than once. is this trade fair?

[Smaug The Dragon]

Hi, there! ^-^ I was wondering if this trade is fair? I KNOW that the spotted tribal is worth 2 sorbets, and I KNOW that the spotted tribal has bad demand. And PLEASE don't give bad information. Thanks t anyone who helps. ^-^

[kököchin]

my apologies for posting here more than once. is this trade fair?

It depends on how you value the joker dog. If you value it at a non, the trade is fair, if you value it at two, then it's unfair to the joker dog <3
Hope this helps!
~Belle~

[hide]

i'm back once again. is this trade fair? thanks in advance!
thank you, béllè and cinder.