The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[NzuriMoyo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61631005&userid=504121&signature=NUdTfSBkb_KM0re6LAlAUA

would this be fair? Warning: there are 1457 items on one side (08 halo, fairies, etc) for one mainlist pet on the other side!
if it isn't fair could anyone tell me what would need to be added/removed to make it fair? thank you!

[The Last Raven]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61635621&userid=796941&signature=-6-zD87p5-wWqYfwlyZgMQ
Not exactly sure how fair this is
Just got this as well:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... chMNAx3M5g

1) overpay. Your pet is worth 7-8 09 rares. Their side has a hyena bun which is already worth 6-7 09 rares + a 09 uncommon. Plus they have added the worth of about 5 (almost 6 I believe) 09 rares.

2) their side is worth 7 09 rares plus a mid 2010 rare (c$ worth) it is on the lower end of being fair to you. The fist one is the better offer.

[puckish]

Which bid is worth more?
one
two

Thanks in advance!

[RareQueen]

Would this pet be worth a 2008 Tier 1 Blue Snowflake Scarf Dog? I really want to accept but I wanted to make sure >-<

I just pulled him from the pound :3

(Also, the person who said the were saving the scarf dog was the person who was trading me the scarf dog xD )

[Eaglespirit]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8qCe4I9fig
How fair is this? What would need added to make it fair? Thanks!

[dogcatalog]

is this fair?

[The Last Raven]

how does this trade look? if unfair, what needs to be added/removed? any help would be appreciated. c:

thank you to both of the previous answers, however I got differing opinions on each. I believe this is slightly unfair to me as a Grinner is worth 14 '09 rares, so what needs to be added? Two more '09 rares? Or am I adding this up wrong?

They have about the worth of about a tier 10 advent right now (10 09 rares). Which means they need to add a low advent list + an 09 rare. Your pet is worth 2 mids + a 09 rare (or a high and a low and a 09 rare).

[justablonde]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... o2llNYLALg

[Keytone]

Would this pet be worth a 2008 Tier 1 Blue Snowflake Scarf Dog? I really want to accept but I wanted to make sure >-<

A Tier 1 Advent is worth about 3-4 '09 rares, and the Mutant can go for 3-4 '09 or low advents like tier 1 & 2 due to it's demand, so it's really up to you and a trading partner whether or not it is! Rarity wise it's just worth '09 rare within three months.

is this fair?

from what i've seen, most people value '16 rares around 1-3$, so it would be slight overpay depending on the person!



i'm crying while i wrote this rollover happened and now everything is grAY. hello april fools day

[AhoyCookie]

trade

Hey! I was wondering if this trade was fair?
I'm extremely unsure, and would like a few opinions.