The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[~{Lazarus}~]

How's this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61617701&userid=787296&signature=AyvNdxKn2LgixaxKM5fdxg

Rarity wise it's very unfair to them, they're offering an 09 rare for a cat worth an early '10 uncommon. Demand wise it depends how you value the cat for it to be fair or not.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61618937&userid=843789&signature=TLJUC2H139Ro1Pqecj8Ebw


is this fair? thank you for ur time

Unfair to you by an early 09 rare.

Is this fair?

Their side is about fair for your dog but not enough to be worth the pony too.

what would make it fair?

[Horror]

is this trade fair demand-wise?

Depends how you value your warrior. If you value it at a '10 rare, it's fair. If you value it as it's worth, it's unfair to them by about 3 '10 uncommons.

what would make it fair?

About another '10 rare on their side. The 2016 pets on their side don't really add up to much.

[pigeon -]

how does this trade look for quantity?
please note that i don't mind a bit of underpay on the sorbet c:

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61615649&userid=642834&signature=3BfM2-WN-mgDOfNCRSge0g

Okay here is the right link sorry /_\!!!!!!

[meows,]

Is this fair? Thank you!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=60938933&userid=738206&signature=hE1JbqbNf7kLmjkgBTSJ-w

Even though the cinnabun has yet to be placed most value it @ a non.

So it depends how you value the joker dog. Do you value it @ above a non? If so then unfair to the joker dog.

If you value it @ a non, it's overpay on the side with the cinnabun, as the cinnabun alone is fair <3

Thank you! Second opinion?

[RareQueen]

Hey guys! this is another bid for my auction! I have a better bid and I'll probably accept that one, but how far would this trade be?

trade x also this?

The first trade is unfair to the other side, the horse alone would be a fair swap for the fish.

The second trade is unfair to the bottom, as the dog is from 2009 I believe (correct me if I'm wrong)

The third trade is unfair to the sorbet, as it's worth a gearback + a dark leopard and the other pets don't add up to that.

Thank you! May I get a second opinion? :3 (Yes, in the second trade the dog is a re-release from August '09)

[Legendarypawprint]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... h_6u8DUjQQ

Hello is this fair? Is not what can I do to make it fair? Thanks!

[Oshawott8888]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61619223&userid=805505&signature=uqgnUEJLWh5kh_6u8DUjQQ

Hello is this fair? Is not what can I do to make it fair? Thanks!

not even close to fair, the eat me drink me set is valued at around a non i believe? and your side adds up to around maybe a low advent ^^
please correct me if i'm wrong

[Legendarypawprint]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61619223&userid=805505&signature=uqgnUEJLWh5kh_6u8DUjQQ

Hello is this fair? Is not what can I do to make it fair? Thanks!

not even close to fair, the eat me drink me set is valued at around a non i believe? and your side adds up to around maybe a low advent ^^
please correct me if i'm wrong

Ok thanks!

[Elettra]

xx This is my bid for an auction - is this fair demand wise /rarity wise? thanks <3