The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Herlock Sholmes]

How's this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61617701&userid=787296&signature=AyvNdxKn2LgixaxKM5fdxg

[pigeon -]

how does this trade look for quantity?
please note that i don't mind a bit of underpay on the sorbet c:

[RareQueen]

Hey guys! this is another bid for my auction! I have a better bid and I'll probably accept that one, but how far would this trade be?

trade x also this?

The first trade is unfair to the other side, the horse alone would be a fair swap for the fish.

The second trade is unfair to the bottom, as the dog is from 2009 I believe (correct me if I'm wrong)

The third trade is unfair to the sorbet, as it's worth a gearback + a dark leopard and the other pets don't add up to that.

Thank you! May I get a second opinion? :3 (Yes, in the second trade the dog is a re-release from August '09)

[Elettra]

xx Help is greatly appreciated! Thank you <3 : )

[Eagle's Eye]

Hey guys! this is another bid for my auction! I have a better bid and I'll probably accept that one, but how far would this trade be?

trade x also this?

The first trade is unfair to the other side, the horse alone would be a fair swap for the fish.

The second trade is unfair to the bottom, as the dog is from 2009 I believe (correct me if I'm wrong)

The third trade is unfair to the sorbet, as it's worth a gearback + a dark leopard and the other pets don't add up to that.

Thank you! May I get a second opinion? :3 (Yes, in the second trade the dog is a re-release from August '09)[/quote]
Don't know about #3, but I agree with 1 and 2.

[lucifer morningstar]

how does this trade look? if unfair, what needs to be added/removed? any help would be appreciated. c:

thank you to both of the previous answers, however I got differing opinions on each. I believe this is slightly unfair to me as a Grinner is worth 14 '09 rares, so what needs to be added? Two more '09 rares? Or am I adding this up wrong?

[Eagle's Eye]

is this trade fair? if not what does it need in order to be fair?
thanks in advance!

Your dog is worth an August '09 uncommon due to it being an extended release pet.
The top should remove everything except for the two 2010 July cats.

[Slumber]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sBKou19VHA
Would this be fair or should I add?

Than you-

[icemagyk]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61618337&userid=717965&signature=7H4Za2NgndwvN3eIn26Drg

how about this ?

that wig sells for 5 c$ in the store, people value old uncommons at different prices so if you value a late 2011 uncommon less than 5 c$ dont take it

[Ally12345]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61618793&userid=843789&signature=-FB3095udDRBF99DLZAydw is this fair?