The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Silverstar]

I don' think this trade is fair, but I wanted to double check.
If not what should be added to make it fair?
(thanks in advance <3)

i would honestly say yes but wait before you say yes because other people might have a better idea of what is worth what

it's very unfair to toxic. It's a main list pet while the store pets don't make a big difference.

[Autumn Ghost]

I don' think this trade is fair, but I wanted to double check.
If not what should be added to make it fair?
(thanks in advance <3)

Id say no, though i'm not completely sure but from experience my Pink Striped Sept did not have great demand and was very hard to trade off, the rest of the pets might not even get you to the top of the September list, I think the green toxic is an overpay by a landslide so not fair at all. The green toxic is worth 41 Mid advents while the PSS is worth 4 mid advents, the rest of the pets wouldn't even or barely at all get you a low tier advent list.

[elio.]

-snip-
-snip-

it's very unfair to toxic. It's a main list pet while the store pets don't make a big difference.

-snip-

Id say no, though i'm not completely sure but from experience my Pink Striped Sept did not have great demand and was very hard to trade off, the rest of the pets might not even get you to the top of the September list, I think the green toxic is an overpay by a landslide so not fair at all. The green toxic is worth 41 Mid advents while the PSS is worth 4 mid advents, the rest of the pets wouldn't even or barely at all get you a low tier advent list.

That's what I was guessing but I'm not sure what should be added to make it fair
trade in question

[Silverstar]

-snip-
-snip-

it's very unfair to toxic. It's a main list pet while the store pets don't make a big difference.

-snip-

Id say no, though i'm not completely sure but from experience my Pink Striped Sept did not have great demand and was very hard to trade off, the rest of the pets might not even get you to the top of the September list, I think the green toxic is an overpay by a landslide so not fair at all. The green toxic is worth 41 Mid advents while the PSS is worth 4 mid advents, the rest of the pets wouldn't even or barely at all get you a low tier advent list.

That's what I was guessing but I'm not sure what should be added to make it fair
trade in question

a nonballoon, two mid advents + candy cane horse tier and a '10 rare.

[Coco Bunny]

Is this fair?

[Kittycentral~]

@Silverstar

Ahh thank you so much for the feedback!! ^^ I'll take that into consideration!

[Flowerlynx]

Is this fair?

I can't tell you yes or no, but here's what I'm thinking.

The grinners have very high demand. They didn't put very many lists on their side of the trade, did they? They mostly did a few quantity uncommons and rares, but most of them aren't even list pets.

[Ariety]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D2O1JVkbTw
is it fair?

[basicbassoonist]

Is this fair?

I can't tell you yes or no, but here's what I'm thinking.

The grinners have very high demand. They didn't put very many lists on their side of the trade, did they? They mostly did a few quantity uncommons and rares, but most of them aren't even list pets.

from what i've experienced, grinners have pretty bad demand. rarity wise, it's worth a Red Dragon + an '09 rare, but it typically goes for less than that because of its demand. the list pets on their side add up to 13-15 '09 rares, or 165C$. taking the grinner's demand into consideration, i think it's a pretty good offer.

[Mykie]

Is this trade fair? I'm not really sure with old pets. Thank you~