"The" Rares List Guide *New* UR Peach Poll! Vote!

Discussion about the Pets, Items, Dress-ups, Events, Site, Forum or other CS features!

Considering the evidence in this post, what would be the best placement for the UR PEACH?

Poll ended at Fri May 18, 2018 2:11 pm

Non Tier (sufficient trade evidence on page 128)
55
22%
UR Holly Tier (sufficient trade evidence on page 128)
51
21%
A new tier between Non & UR Holly (middle ground between both tiers)
93
38%
I don't know but want to participate
46
19%
 
Total votes : 245

Re: "The" Rares List Guide - UR peach discussion, come help!

Postby mikasi-nightwolf » Wed Jan 10, 2018 5:53 pm

Today Jan 09 2017 : I Traded my Peach for a Sorbet + Flower Pot ( Worth 2.5 Sorbets ) . So that’s for 3.5 Sorbets worth which is roughly little over a non or worth one non. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MYfAz6HlZg
User avatar
mikasi-nightwolf
 
Posts: 3907
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 12:36 pm
My pets
My items
My wishlist
My gallery
My scenes
My dressups
Trade with me

Re: "The" Rares List Guide - UR peach discussion, come help!

Postby TheLittleBlackCat » Thu Jan 11, 2018 7:50 pm

mikasi-nightwolf wrote:Today Jan 09 2017 : I Traded my Peach for a Sorbet + Flower Pot ( Worth 2.5 Sorbets ) . So that’s for 3.5 Sorbets worth which is roughly little over a non or worth one non. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MYfAz6HlZg


You might struggle getting the 2.5 sorbets worth for the flower however

Not to say that it's not worth that much, it is, though some people have just been spreading round that it's only worth 1 sorbet.. (so in your trader's eyes, they could've thought they were trading 2 sorbets worth for the peach. All depends on perception)

I got my flower from someone who only wanted 1 sorbet for it (though I didn't have a sorbet so I traded a blue toxic instead):


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2V6N5GkTTA

And that was at 2017-11-11

-

Also,another thing. Why are people now valuing the red cerb at 1-3 nons worth? Heck, when I had one back in 2014, the best I could get was an extremely low mainlist.. (as well as people offering 1 batdog or 1 raven dog but I just presumed they had similar demand to the cerb at the time)


Granted I later got this offer in 2016-03-07(and no, I'm not offering this trade up to the peach discussion as the cerb's worth is hard to gauge demandwise, though rarity wise this would've been unfair to the peach):


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aXTd2LDl6w



Granted I kinda had a mini break throughout most of 2015 so I don't know what the cerb was going for during that time though hey, when I got offered a peach for it, my first thought was "well, this is a lot more than everything else I've been offered in the past. Maybe I should accept it"

Which now just makes me wonder why people are now saying the cerb is currently going for 1-3 nons in 2018?
User avatar
TheLittleBlackCat
 
Posts: 16039
Joined: Sat Aug 30, 2014 6:18 am
My pets
My items
My wishlist
My gallery
My scenes
My dressups
Trade with me

Re: "The" Rares List Guide - UR peach discussion, come help!

Postby mikasi-nightwolf » Thu Jan 11, 2018 7:57 pm

TheLittleBlackCat wrote:
mikasi-nightwolf wrote:Today Jan 09 2017 : I Traded my Peach for a Sorbet + Flower Pot ( Worth 2.5 Sorbets ) . So that’s for 3.5 Sorbets worth which is roughly little over a non or worth one non. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MYfAz6HlZg


You might struggle getting the 2.5 sorbets worth for the flower however

Not to say that it's not worth that much, it is, though some people have just been spreading round that it's only worth 1 sorbet.. (so in your trader's eyes, they could've thought they were trading 2 sorbets worth for the peach. All depends on perception)

I got my flower from someone who only wanted 1 sorbet for it (though I didn't have a sorbet so I traded a blue toxic instead):


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2V6N5GkTTA

And that was at 2017-11-11

-

Also,another thing. Why are people now valuing the red cerb at 1-3 nons worth? Heck, when I had one back in 2014, the best I could get was an extremely low mainlist.. (as well as people offering 1 batdog or 1 raven dog but I just presumed they had similar demand to the cerb at the time)


Granted I later got this offer in 2016-03-07(and no, I'm not offering this trade up to the peach discussion as the cerb's worth is hard to gauge demandwise, though rarity wise this would've been unfair to the peach):


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aXTd2LDl6w



Granted I kinda had a mini break throughout most of 2015 so I don't know what the cerb was going for during that time though hey, when I got offered a peach for it, my first thought was "well, this is a lot more than everything else I've been offered in the past. Maybe I should accept it"

Which now just makes me wonder why people are now saying the cerb is currently going for 1-3 nons in 2018?


So far everyone iv asked do value it at 2.5 Sorbets. :/ Just gotta be pateint to who wants to give me that, or a non for the flower and the sorbet. I beleive in value more then demand cause their was alot of demand talk here, and from now on i go by worth not demand. Others can do what they please, and so can i lol . I beleive in being fair not asking crazy amount for pets you know?
User avatar
mikasi-nightwolf
 
Posts: 3907
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 12:36 pm
My pets
My items
My wishlist
My gallery
My scenes
My dressups
Trade with me

Re: "The" Rares List Guide - UR peach discussion, come help!

Postby TheLittleBlackCat » Thu Jan 11, 2018 8:01 pm

mikasi-nightwolf wrote:
TheLittleBlackCat wrote:
mikasi-nightwolf wrote:Today Jan 09 2017 : I Traded my Peach for a Sorbet + Flower Pot ( Worth 2.5 Sorbets ) . So that’s for 3.5 Sorbets worth which is roughly little over a non or worth one non. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MYfAz6HlZg


You might struggle getting the 2.5 sorbets worth for the flower however

Not to say that it's not worth that much, it is, though some people have just been spreading round that it's only worth 1 sorbet.. (so in your trader's eyes, they could've thought they were trading 2 sorbets worth for the peach. All depends on perception)

I got my flower from someone who only wanted 1 sorbet for it (though I didn't have a sorbet so I traded a blue toxic instead):


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2V6N5GkTTA

And that was at 2017-11-11

-

Also,another thing. Why are people now valuing the red cerb at 1-3 nons worth? Heck, when I had one back in 2014, the best I could get was an extremely low mainlist.. (as well as people offering 1 batdog or 1 raven dog but I just presumed they had similar demand to the cerb at the time)


Granted I later got this offer in 2016-03-07(and no, I'm not offering this trade up to the peach discussion as the cerb's worth is hard to gauge demandwise, though rarity wise this would've been unfair to the peach):


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aXTd2LDl6w



Granted I kinda had a mini break throughout most of 2015 so I don't know what the cerb was going for during that time though hey, when I got offered a peach for it, my first thought was "well, this is a lot more than everything else I've been offered in the past. Maybe I should accept it"

Which now just makes me wonder why people are now saying the cerb is currently going for 1-3 nons in 2018?


So far everyone iv asked do value it at 2.5 Sorbets. :/ Just gotta be pateint to who wants to give me that, or a non for the flower and the sorbet. I beleive in value more then demand cause their was alot of demand talk here, and from now on i go by worth not demand. Others can do what they please, and so can i lol . I beleive in being fair not asking crazy amount for pets you know?


True true, I wasn't saying you couldn't get 2.5 sorbets worth for the flower, I was just saying you might struggle

Sometimes I just don't get the demand with fruit and some more disliked mini-pets.. they're adorable.. it's just a pitty some look like they're rotting and people value them to be so low..
User avatar
TheLittleBlackCat
 
Posts: 16039
Joined: Sat Aug 30, 2014 6:18 am
My pets
My items
My wishlist
My gallery
My scenes
My dressups
Trade with me

Re: "The" Rares List Guide - UR peach discussion, come help!

Postby mikasi-nightwolf » Thu Jan 11, 2018 8:12 pm

TheLittleBlackCat wrote:
mikasi-nightwolf wrote:
So far everyone iv asked do value it at 2.5 Sorbets. :/ Just gotta be pateint to who wants to give me that, or a non for the flower and the sorbet. I beleive in value more then demand cause their was alot of demand talk here, and from now on i go by worth not demand. Others can do what they please, and so can i lol . I beleive in being fair not asking crazy amount for pets you know?


True true, I wasn't saying you couldn't get 2.5 sorbets worth for the flower, I was just saying you might struggle

Sometimes I just don't get the demand with fruit and some more disliked mini-pets.. they're adorable.. it's just a pitty some look like they're rotting and people value them to be so low..


I agree!, I love the peach and he flower, they are so adorable! I honestly think they should be valued higher cause their isn't anything like them! their are a million different dogs or cats, but only one peach and one flower :/ people are weird lol.
User avatar
mikasi-nightwolf
 
Posts: 3907
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 12:36 pm
My pets
My items
My wishlist
My gallery
My scenes
My dressups
Trade with me

Re: "The" Rares List Guide - UR peach discussion, come help!

Postby TheLittleBlackCat » Thu Jan 11, 2018 8:26 pm

mikasi-nightwolf wrote:
TheLittleBlackCat wrote:
mikasi-nightwolf wrote:
So far everyone iv asked do value it at 2.5 Sorbets. :/ Just gotta be pateint to who wants to give me that, or a non for the flower and the sorbet. I beleive in value more then demand cause their was alot of demand talk here, and from now on i go by worth not demand. Others can do what they please, and so can i lol . I beleive in being fair not asking crazy amount for pets you know?


True true, I wasn't saying you couldn't get 2.5 sorbets worth for the flower, I was just saying you might struggle

Sometimes I just don't get the demand with fruit and some more disliked mini-pets.. they're adorable.. it's just a pitty some look like they're rotting and people value them to be so low..


I agree!, I love the peach and he flower, they are so adorable! I honestly think they should be valued higher cause their isn't anything like them! their are a million different dogs or cats, but only one peach and one flower :/ people are weird lol.


That's true

A part of me wonders if they're hated because their so different? But that doesn't make sense mainly as if that was the case, Malk pets would have lower demand, but they don't and are highly sought after.. maybe it's because they're fruit as so people don't consider them a great enough concept to become pets?

TBH I like the fruits also, heck I have a banana and flower of my own that I don't intend on trading unless i get an offer I really like
User avatar
TheLittleBlackCat
 
Posts: 16039
Joined: Sat Aug 30, 2014 6:18 am
My pets
My items
My wishlist
My gallery
My scenes
My dressups
Trade with me

Re: "The" Rares List Guide - UR peach discussion, come help!

Postby mikasi-nightwolf » Thu Jan 11, 2018 8:29 pm

TheLittleBlackCat wrote:

That's true

A part of me wonders if they're hated because their so different? But that doesn't make sense mainly as if that was the case, Malk pets would have lower demand, but they don't and are highly sought after.. maybe it's because they're fruit as so people don't consider them a great enough concept to become pets?

TBH I like the fruits also, heck I have a banana and flower of my own that I don't intend on trading unless i get an offer I really like


If I wasn’t trying to get my dreamie ( non swirl ) I would of never of traded my peach away! It’s so adorable! Next time I ever get one I don’t plan on letting it go.
User avatar
mikasi-nightwolf
 
Posts: 3907
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 12:36 pm
My pets
My items
My wishlist
My gallery
My scenes
My dressups
Trade with me

Re: "The" Rares List Guide - UR peach discussion, come help!

Postby Topsy Turvey » Thu Jan 11, 2018 9:03 pm

mikasi-nightwolf wrote:
TheLittleBlackCat wrote:

That's true

A part of me wonders if they're hated because their so different? But that doesn't make sense mainly as if that was the case, Malk pets would have lower demand, but they don't and are highly sought after.. maybe it's because they're fruit as so people don't consider them a great enough concept to become pets?

TBH I like the fruits also, heck I have a banana and flower of my own that I don't intend on trading unless i get an offer I really like


If I wasn’t trying to get my dreamie ( non swirl ) I would of never of traded my peach away! It’s so adorable! Next time I ever get one I don’t plan on letting it go.

I honestly would've loved them if they were slightly more realistic? I love the Peach's design but I don't like the Caterpillar, I live the apple/grapes/banana/pickle/Peapod but I don't like that they're either rotten, sad or both. I love the Cinnabun because it has a cute design but no real twist to it like there is with the others. Hence the reason that I value the Peach at about 2 Sorbets because like me, people don't tend have much of an opinion on them. Sure they may swing more towards liking the Peach than not liking it but they don't genuinely like it either so they may not want to trade for it unless it's a good deal but a non is the height of their demand and not considered a good deal however 1-2 sorbets is. Of course as the value lowers so does the demand which is why I think about the Flower/Spotted Tirbal tier is a suitable spot c:
Image
Image

________________________




I am a holibomber!
I have gifted 6 people.
I have received 4 gifts.








I'm currently trying to clean out my lair,
Click on the link above to see what I have,
If there anything you like just offer!
User avatar
Topsy Turvey
 
Posts: 9170
Joined: Fri Oct 02, 2009 7:05 pm
My pets
My items
My wishlist
My gallery
My scenes
My dressups
Trade with me

Re: "The" Rares List Guide - UR peach discussion, come help!

Postby leru » Thu Jan 11, 2018 9:14 pm

    Not related to the Peach but here's all the trades I did for my 8 Zonkeys:

    one
    two
    three
    four
    five
    six
    seven (was to a friend, I know that I overpaid by 1-2 nons)
x
will be gone from the 14th - 23rd of feb
zonkey hoarder | characters | trade thread
User avatar
leru
 
Posts: 756
Joined: Sat May 03, 2014 9:10 pm
My pets
My items
My wishlist
My gallery
My scenes
My dressups
Trade with me

Re: "The" Rares List Guide - UR peach discussion, come help!

Postby LongLiveRegina » Fri Jan 12, 2018 6:27 am

Hello! please redirect me if this goes somewhere else but I'm trying to understand a bit more about trades and the list so that i can help out more in the "fair trade" thread and have a couple of questions.

Whats the gap between each tier. i understand that its one '09 rare on the advent list and that the gap gets bigger as you go further up the list but how do i work out the gaps further up??

Edit: i do also look at the gaps list but i mean more like if someone offers a few advents for a high september, how do i work out the fairness? and also if someone offers a high september for a low september and a load of rares?? :)

also, how do i work out how many '09 rares a september or mainlist is worth?

Thank you so much for any advice that is given!:) please feel free to leave some more advice to help me help others :mrgreen:

xoxo
User avatar
LongLiveRegina
 
Posts: 4457
Joined: Thu Dec 19, 2013 4:10 am
My pets
My items
My wishlist
My gallery
My scenes
My dressups
Trade with me

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: defresh, J-and-K341, Jackaby, Jedi Master Lady Ren, Puddin_Pie, SylverTears, ThisIsGospel, Xeroxoe and 0 guests