*DISCONTINUED* Rares List Guide (1 March 2019)

[myth;]

Any more opinions on vote options?

[Takk]

Suppose I don’t have an issue with the three choices, tho I’m still against adding it to the Sunjewel tier being recently OMGSR but it doesn’t seem like a popular realization at the moment
I’m in favor of the dogtag and moon swirl tiers for sure if we don’t wanna add the zebras (the gap isn’t huge anyway)

[DarknessANDLight]

I know This has nothing to do with the current discussion, But should The Very rare zebra be moved down the list?
Also I think the options for the poll should be:
Dogtag tier
New tier in between Dogtag and moonswirl (3 nons and a Purple toxic)
Moonswirl tier

[myth;]

I think it'd cause too much confusion adding another tier to the main list, and I think we need to keep the sun jewel option there because people are offering them and more for skelebuns.

[EmberzTale]

I think it'd cause too much confusion adding another tier to the main list, and I think we need to keep the sun jewel option there because people are offering them and more for skelebuns.

I agree. The Skelebun doesn't seem to commonly go for inbetween the two tiers anyways and a lot of users are offering Tiger Dogs and Sunjewels in exchange for a Skelebun.

[DarknessANDLight]

I think it'd cause too much confusion adding another tier to the main list, and I think we need to keep the sun jewel option there because people are offering them and more for skelebuns.

I agree. The Skelebun doesn't seem to commonly go for inbetween the two tiers anyways and a lot of users are offering Tiger Dogs and Sunjewels in exchange for a Skelebun.

I have never seen someone offer a UR tiger dog for a skelebun?

[ElementalInsanity]

I think it'd cause too much confusion adding another tier to the main list, and I think we need to keep the sun jewel option there because people are offering them and more for skelebuns.

I agree. The Skelebun doesn't seem to commonly go for inbetween the two tiers anyways and a lot of users are offering Tiger Dogs and Sunjewels in exchange for a Skelebun.

Agreed. This really isn’t a case where we need to make a new tier, whereas the Peach was.

And I totally get your concerns Takk, with adding it to the sunjewel tier.
I myself would be happy enough with two choices of the moonswirl and dogtag tiers, tbh, because if people want to pay overpay with a sunjewel they totally still can? And will, as we all know how CS goes now.
But it also keeps it from being on the ‘top tier’ of this bible ‘guide’.
While yes, it gets enough offers of sunjewel it can still get those offers at a lower tier. Believe me, that won’t stop people from overpaying.

Mostly I’ve seen offers around the moonswirl tier tbh? With a few throwing out just a straight swap for the sunjewel out of DEMAND desperation. Which I do NOT want to feed?

However I have never seen an offer of a UR Tiger Dog for one. Not a straight swap at least.

Edit: And if we can’t come to a solid agreement on tiers, we could run two polls similar to what we did for the peach. Four tier options (sunjewel, moonswirl, dogtag, zebra) and then go with the two highest voted tiers from there? Just throwing out ideas here.



All in all I personally agree with takk and think if we aren’t wanting to focus so much on demand here, which we shouldn’t as we didn’t with the peach, then perhaps the sunjewel shouldn’t be an option yet.

[myth;]

However I have never seen an offer of a UR Tiger Dog for one. Not a straight swap at least.

I have, once and a long time ago, after it went OMGSR I do believe.. I'll try and find the trade tomorrow.

You've got a good point however, at least if it's lower people won't be obliged to trade it for a top tier list pet.. though I think the option should still be there, the most likely case is that no one will choose that option anyway. Because, let's be honest, who really wants to offer 5 nons for a skelebun.

[ElementalInsanity]

However I have never seen an offer of a UR Tiger Dog for one. Not a straight swap at least.

I have, once and a long time ago, after it went OMGSR I do believe.. I'll try and find the trade tomorrow.

You've got a good point however, at least if it's lower people won't be obliged to trade it for a top tier list pet.. though I think the option should still be there, the most likely case is that no one will choose that option anyway. Because, let's be honest, who really wants to offer 5 nons for a skelebun.

Then that was a demand based offer, correct? I feel it was for the Tiger dog, a sudden spike to it being OMGSR and someone had to extremely overpay to get their hands on it. More an outlier demand overpay. =)

And honestly, I don’t quite agree lol. People are offering five nons and MORE for the skelebun. If you’ve seen the offers I’ve got I have received at least three straight offers for a sunjewel. So again, what would we do if that was the most voted for option? That’s a really demand focused placing, and tier option.

I wouldn’t be opposed to the tiers that Takk suggested. I also would not be opposed for all four being an option, as I suggested, and then doing a secondary poll with the two highest options as we did with peach.

It’ll just depend on what everyone else agrees on I suppose?

Also I’m still hoping that a volunteer might be able to collect the offers that have been posted in this thread, and perhaps some trades? Takk, I’m not sure if you’d be up to doing that again? I can help with what’s been posted in this thread I think, when I have the time.

[myth;]

Oh I know it gets offers of more than 5 nons, I have one myself. XD But no one really wants to trade that much, if given the choice. I started out offering 2 nons for a skelebun, before I built it to 5.. and then, well, the trade I made for mine has so many others mixed in that it's not really possible to use it as a standing block.

I may be able to gather the trades tomorrow, unless something comes up in RL.