closed! go to new thread c:

[Planet Karma]

Was this fair?
They cancelled saying it was a '12 rerelease and I was fully aware of that thinking this was fair. What is it I missed?

Not many people will trade a rare for an uncommon. It'd be unfair rarity wise. Some go by 2x Uncommons = 1 Rare... Not sure whether the item does fill up for an Uncommon, maybe they just didn't like the things offered.

But offering 2 '11 uncommons would have made it unfair.

[chlobeni]

was this fair for my cucumber demand wise?
thanks in advance!

Demand wise, yes. It is very rare to see cucumbers go for more than a non.

[~Misty]

was this fair for my cucumber demand wise?
thanks in advance!

To be honest, yes I would say so.
None of the fruits have good demand, a non would have been a good swap. They have no special demand, but go for their worth. Not many would go out of their way to get a UR Cucumber.

[Strawberryice]

Oh geez.... ok I'm looking for personal opinions and demand wise please!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u31jvce40w
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wUfDY_2Q2w
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 07o-KeIyoQ
Thanks in advance!
Please note I'm valuing my UR cinnamon bun at a non/+ or a little lower. It is not placed on list! So please don't tell me that it is worth a sorbet or non and something like that.

All I know if the first is unfair

[~Misty]

Was this fair?
They cancelled saying it was a '12 rerelease and I was fully aware of that thinking this was fair. What is it I missed?

Not many people will trade a rare for an uncommon. It'd be unfair rarity wise. Some go by 2x Uncommons = 1 Rare... Not sure whether the item does fill up for an Uncommon, maybe they just didn't like the things offered.

But offering 2 '11 uncommons would have made it unfair.

No, not really, it depends on personal thoughts. I offer 2x of the same year Uncommons for Rares, most get cancelled though as nobody really trades down rarities.

[swallows]

Would this be fair?
(There is a UR Aussie on my side)

[Archiy]

Oh geez.... ok I'm looking for personal opinions and demand wise please!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u31jvce40w
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wUfDY_2Q2w
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 07o-KeIyoQ
Thanks in advance!
Please note I'm valuing my UR cinnamon bun at a non/+ or a little lower. It is not placed on list! So please don't tell me that it is worth a sorbet or non and something like that.

All I know if the first is unfair

Could you explain why?

[~Misty]

Oh geez.... ok I'm looking for personal opinions and demand wise please!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u31jvce40w
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wUfDY_2Q2w
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 07o-KeIyoQ
Thanks in advance!
Please note I'm valuing my UR cinnamon bun at a non/+ or a little lower. It is not placed on list! So please don't tell me that it is worth a sorbet or non and something like that.

All I know if the first is unfair

No, you're quite wrong. The first trade wouldn't be unfair. Generally the UR Bwolf goes for a Non + Sorbet, maybe a low toxic in place of the sorbet. The most I have seen it go for is 2x Nons.
I'd say the middle is fairest, but I can't really answer that as I sent it.

[Sarin]

Oh geez.... ok I'm looking for personal opinions and demand wise please!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u31jvce40w
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wUfDY_2Q2w
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 07o-KeIyoQ
Thanks in advance!
Please note I'm valuing my UR cinnamon bun at a non/+ or a little lower. It is not placed on list! So please don't tell me that it is worth a sorbet or non and something like that.

All I know if the first is unfair

No, you're quite wrong. The first trade wouldn't be unfair. Generally the UR Bwolf goes for a Non + Sorbet, maybe a low toxic in place of the sorbet. The most I have seen it go for is 2x Nons.
I'd say the middle is fairest, but I can't really answer that as I sent it.

I can't really say which is fair as the cinnabun doesn't have a set value, but the middle trade does look like the best value to me. The UR B-wolf and the GWJ both have poor demand, while I think the Hollywing's demand is more stable.

[Archiy]

Oh geez.... ok I'm looking for personal opinions and demand wise please!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u31jvce40w
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wUfDY_2Q2w
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 07o-KeIyoQ
Thanks in advance!
Please note I'm valuing my UR cinnamon bun at a non/+ or a little lower. It is not placed on list! So please don't tell me that it is worth a sorbet or non and something like that.

All I know if the first is unfair

No, you're quite wrong. The first trade wouldn't be unfair. Generally the UR Bwolf goes for a Non + Sorbet, maybe a low toxic in place of the sorbet. The most I have seen it go for is 2x Nons.
I'd say the middle is fairest, but I can't really answer that as I sent it. - #wolfdog

I can't really say which is fair as the cinnabun doesn't have a set value, but the middle trade does look like the best value to me. The UR B-wolf and the GWJ both have poor demand, while I think the Hollywing's demand is more stable.

Thank you to all