Please visit new thread!

[Goostarion]

I have a few bids for my Apple, which one is the most fair? And for the last trade, how much are they overpaying?

bids;

x 2/10 -there aren't any list pets, and this is definitely not fair.-
x 4/10 -there's a listie in there, but I don't think that this is fair-
x + art • 8/10 -absolutely amazing art! LEADING-
x 4/10 -there's a list pet there, but it's a tier 5 advent-
x 7/10 -the heavy speckled rat is an overpay by about a 'insert pet here'-

The thing to note is that... I have no idea how to answer you because of how you have the Leading bid including art. The art is valued depending on what you are willing to pay and what they are willing to draw and in that term it becomes a commission and no longer an auction of sorts.

The closest to fair is the Speckled rat given the circumstances given. They are overpaying by approximately a Scarf PPS.

[zerkyo.]

Was it wise of me to accept this?

Keeping in mind the demand of the Non Jewel AND the Sun Jewel.
What could I get for a Sun Jewel / Non Jewel?

This also?

[Ꭺlina]

Which one is the best?
trade 1
trade 2
trade 3
Please keep in mind the demand of the sunback, as I've been offered a sunjewel for it
Thanks in advance!

[Goostarion]

Which one is the best?
trade 1
trade 2
trade 3
Please keep in mind the demand of the sunback, as I've been offered a sunjewel for it
Thanks in advance!

Demand is something that changes from person to person. Since this is the "is this a fair trade thread", answering with the whole "keep in mind the demand because I have been offered 'x' for it previously" is pretty much invalidated when the question being asked is if it is fair. Quoting from DaDwarf: "There's normal demand/actual/natural/speciesbased demand, there's greedy demand/i-want-more-cause-i-paid-more type and then there's repeated/added demand/i-saw-it-go-for-this-so-now-it-is-worth-this-demand."

This doesn't change it's worth. If you value a pet to be worth more than it is because of demand, ultimately I would be lying to you if I answered considering demand in that regard. This is why I am answering down the middle straight up. Demand I consider would be different to demand you may consider. And that probably goes for pretty much anyone who answers here considering how the rarity and rare's list works.

With that said.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NoW0qWu4jA
Unfair to them by pretty much two UR Lions. Give or take depending on how you value.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ViQ0oHEh9Q
Unfair to you by a lot. Their side technically only adds up to a Ur Lion plus at maximum anywhere between a balloon tier and a Line tribal tier.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GrptbH1fXg
Unfair to you. Their side isn't even worth a UR Aussie if you squint and look at it.

By all accounts, you don't loose if you take the first one, and you loose a lot if you take the other two. This is strictly speaking in regards to worth, no demand. In any case, all trades here are unfair one way or another. With that said, I hope this helps you somehow ^^

Good luck regardless! c:

[Rinsea]

someone sent me this suggestion. Why needs to be added on either side to make it fair? (Please also consider demand of the pets) Thanks in advance!

also what's the demand of the ur foal?

[Silverstar]

someone sent me this suggestion. Why needs to be added on either side to make it fair? (Please also consider demand of the pets) Thanks in advance!

also what's the demand of the ur foal?

A CE Galaxy + a skeleton pps.
The foal has average demand, it's not hard to trade it off.

[justina valentine]

What does a dog tag usually go for?
Also should i accept this;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OWDOZvOI4A
Also if someone is really good at their rares list i need some help with bids so please pm if you can help me

[Galaxyofstars,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Z-q09DhOKw

Was this fair?

[Goostarion]

Was it wise of me to accept this?

Keeping in mind the demand of the Non Jewel AND the Sun Jewel.
What could I get for a Sun Jewel / Non Jewel?

This also?

I am absolutely terrible when it comes to baby list pets being born, never really had them to experience the whole day they are born and that jazz. With that said, I can definitely say the second one is unfair to the Gearback by quite a bit. By nearly three times the worth of the blue balloon to be specific. I don't know about the other one unfortunately.

someone sent me this suggestion. Why needs to be added on either side to make it fair? (Please also consider demand of the pets) Thanks in advance!

also what's the demand of the ur foal?

I don't answer with demand taken into consideration as demand varies between person and person and refer to the Rare's list strictly when replying to ensure a trade is fair, since this is the "Is this a fair trade" thread. In this case, it is extremely unfair to the UR Foal. By a lot.

[Rinsea]

someone sent me this suggestion. Why needs to be added on either side to make it fair? (Please also consider demand of the pets) Thanks in advance!

also what's the demand of the ur foal?

A CE Galaxy + a skeleton pps.
The foal has average demand, it's not hard to trade it off.

thanks for the advice! Can i get another opinion to be sure?