The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[justina valentine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ilo3qqS8Uw
Should i accept? c:

[kim seok-jin]

no, its a re-release already and the 2009 would be enough anyway, don't accept its not fair.

[SaltyTrigger]

is this fair to me?

I would say it's slight overpay to the top. Though I really like that dog, so I wouldn't personally accept it. That is my personal opinion though.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58884680&userid=769336&signature=lYOkhnjii0xpIlo3qqS8Uw
Should i accept? c:

Due to the demand of the 'true' warrior cats, this isn't an uncommon trade. It just depends on how much you want the cat.

[pigeon.enthusiast]

I have no idea!
Please help!

Value wise they are overpaying as the zebra is higher on the Mainlist than the UR Cat
Demand wise the UR cat is worth more

I personally wouldn't take it since the UR Cat has more demand which means you can fetch more :3
Hope this helps

Anyone else?

Agreed

One last opinion, anyone? x3

[L.V.L]

Thank you in advance!! <3

[justina valentine]

[

I have no idea!
Please help!

Value wise they are overpaying as the zebra is higher on the Mainlist than the UR Cat
Demand wise the UR cat is worth more

I personally wouldn't take it since the UR Cat has more demand which means you can fetch more :3
Hope this helps

\
Agreed

One last opinion, anyone? x3

I agree plus the ur cat has a lot more demand than the zebra i would decline this offer

[Vanillasaur]

Anyone know if this is fair?

[justina valentine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ilo3qqS8Uw
Should i accept? c:

Due to the demand of the 'true' warrior cats, this isn't an uncommon trade. It just depends on how much you want the cat.[/quote]
Okay thanks second opinion please? c:

[inkyst]

Is this trade fair?

[justina valentine]

Anyone know if this is fair?

No no, your way over!