The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Scarlett.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58710803&userid=29150&signature=tu3WBI-emgECSQbxu7hJkQ Any help with this? Those VR have me like O.O

Also this, this causes me great pain because I'm so tempted. Is it techically an overpay with the OMGSR?: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lwSPI4WRRQ

Aand this one has me stumped.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NqeFv8_fGw

Any help is super appreciated! Again, a little something to whoever can help. c:

For the UR Foal trade, I think you're overpaying rarity wise.
They offered a UR Foal which is below the gap for a Non AND Rose PPS? Nons are worth a UR Flower + Green toxic, and together with the Rose PPS, that's overpay for just a UR Foal. I wouldn't take the trade but it's ultimately up to you if you like the OMGSR rating c:

[Leopardy]

Also this, this causes me great pain because I'm so tempted. Is it techically an overpay with the OMGSR?: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lwSPI4WRRQ

Aand this one has me stumped.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NqeFv8_fGw

Any help is super appreciated! Again, a little something to whoever can help. c:

So, first trade, the UR Foal (what they are offering) isn´t a fair trade to your Pet, the Dogtag.
Yours is above the big gap, theirs is the Purple Toxic Level and I know for a fact that they need to add some Rareslist Pets.
Maybe someone on here can tell you exactly what they need to add, because I´m not exactly sure.

Second Trade is also unfair to you. Your Dogtag is already higher than their UR Phoenix and the added other Pets to your side. Just don´t accept, that´s not fair to you at all.

[J.cole]

Also this, this causes me great pain because I'm so tempted. Is it techically an overpay with the OMGSR?: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lwSPI4WRRQ

Aand this one has me stumped.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NqeFv8_fGw

Any help is super appreciated! Again, a little something to whoever can help. c:

So, first trade, the UR Foal (what they are offering) isn´t a fair trade to your Pet, the Dogtag.
Yours is above the big gap, theirs is the Purple Toxic Level and I know for a fact that they need to add some Rareslist Pets.
Maybe someone on here can tell you exactly what they need to add, because I´m not exactly sure.

Second Trade is also unfair to you. Your Dogtag is already higher than their UR Phoenix and the added other Pets to your side. Just don´t accept, that´s not fair to you at all.

Thats not dog tag. thats Non tag. But you are overtrading though.

[Laetificat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58716742&userid=596560&signature=yLox6uup86tpr2NCYrnzeQ

What should be added to my side to make up for the bad demand of the rat, and the good demand of their cat?

[kxynine]

So im having an auction, and i wanna know which of those bids is worth more?
Also, have i been giving the right advise? (Whatever you call it)

Bids;
bid 1 Many have said its fair but i dont really like the Nick pet. IF you change it to a higher demand or something like that its great!
bid 2 I can get a high september lost for it and 2 rares and few commons isnt enough sorry ;-;
bid 3 Again, a few storepets and a few rares and some commons-uncommons isnt enough ;-;
bid 4 Its a nice bid! ^^ May be auto but idk imma get some advice <3
bid 5 I love the bid! Tho im most likely looking for lists x3 *Leading bid for now*
bid 6 This isnt fair at all sorry :c Theres only one rare i think and thats just not enough xc

[Leopardy]

Also this, this causes me great pain because I'm so tempted. Is it techically an overpay with the OMGSR?: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lwSPI4WRRQ

Aand this one has me stumped.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NqeFv8_fGw

Any help is super appreciated! Again, a little something to whoever can help. c:

So, first trade, the UR Foal (what they are offering) isn´t a fair trade to your Pet, the Dogtag.
Yours is above the big gap, theirs is the Purple Toxic Level and I know for a fact that they need to add some Rareslist Pets.
Maybe someone on here can tell you exactly what they need to add, because I´m not exactly sure.

Second Trade is also unfair to you. Your Dogtag is already higher than their UR Phoenix and the added other Pets to your side. Just don´t accept, that´s not fair to you at all.

Thats not dog tag. thats Non tag. But you are overtrading though.

Ah, I always get them confused ^^"
Thanks for correcting!
Allthough, I´m not too sure about the second trade than

[J.cole]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zoHkRoKZ-g is this demand and rarity wise fair?

[bunny fluff]

What is the demand these days for nons? How are these demand wise and which one is better?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0ha7Pa2cUg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... g6t8hvg1fA

I still havent been answered. Thank you in advance to whomever does

[lola843]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58710803&userid=29150&signature=tu3WBI-emgECSQbxu7hJkQ Any help with this? Those VR have me like O.O

Also this, this causes me great pain because I'm so tempted. Is it techically an overpay with the OMGSR?: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lwSPI4WRRQ

Aand this one has me stumped.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NqeFv8_fGw

Any help is super appreciated! Again, a little something to whoever can help. c:

For the UR Foal trade, I think you're overpaying rarity wise.
They offered a UR Foal which is below the gap for a Non AND Rose PPS? Nons are worth a UR Flower + Green toxic, and together with the Rose PPS, that's overpay for just a UR Foal. I wouldn't take the trade but it's ultimately up to you if you like the OMGSR rating c:

Thank you all so much for helping!!

[kijauni]

Is this fair for a Blue Sorbet?

Or this Trade?