The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Shadow2204]

is the Cheshire cat a fair trade for a smiley? i'm not sure but i don't this so
please pm me
also what is this pet worth? i get trades for it almost ever week. thanks

Pet's name: Psychedeli ♥
Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!

A Cheshire cat would be overpay for the smiley. The cat has more demand and it's worth more rarity wise anyway.
That's the PPS Aussie. Aussies tend to get a lot of trades since they are in demand & goes for overpay.

[~Loki~]

Is this fair?

[lucky333123]

Is this fair?

Unfair to them. Both of their pets combined together will equal about a '09 rare. The 2 '09 uncommons will not equal the rare.

[kxynine]

Is this fair?

Unfair to them. Both of their pets combined together will equal about a '09 rare. The 2 '09 uncommons will not equal the rare.

I might have to disaggrre (cant spell ;-;)The 2 uncommons is warrior cats and has some demand. I'd say its a bit unfair but hey, its my opinion.

[lucifer morningstar]

could I get an opinion on this trade? if unfair, what needs to be added/removed?
any help would be appreciated. c:
-lucifer morningstar

[Eagle's Eye]

could I get an opinion on this trade? if unfair, what needs to be added/removed?
any help would be appreciated. c:
-lucifer morningstar

Their side is only worth a 2010 rare and a 2015 rare
I'd suggest removing all the non store pets on their side and add another 2010 rare since the pets are too recent to worth much

[Silverstar]

could I get an opinion on this trade? if unfair, what needs to be added/removed?
any help would be appreciated. c:
-lucifer morningstar

A '16 store pet is worth a late '10 rare, it's unfair to them. Two '16 store pets are fair for your dog.

[Kyar]

could I get an opinion on this trade? if unfair, what needs to be added/removed?
any help would be appreciated. c:
-lucifer morningstar

A '16 store pet is worth a late '10 rare, it's unfair to them. Two '16 store pets are fair for your dog.

I think you might've misspoken lol. That would make it unfair to the bottom - to which I agree. :)

[ilya]

Is this fair? I know the halloween candy item can go for older rares,but i'm not good with quantity...

[Pastelaj]

Was this fair to the both of us?